4 ms·
I'm only 20% through, but I thought I'd comment on the first section of "Don'ts". It's basically saying that Google's strategy with VP8/VP9 sucked. I don't agre
by ZeroGravitas 12y ago
I'm only 20% through, but I thought I'd comment on the first section of "Don'ts". It's basically saying that Google's strategy with VP8/VP9 sucked. I don't agree. They took on a massive task and have had some small successes. It could have gone much worse. It reminds me a bit of those business books that look at firms that succeeded and cargo-cult everything they did or didn't do. But many of the factors that hold you back are random contingencies.
The big stumbling blocks for open web codecs are Microsoft/IE (on the desktop) and Apple/Safari (on mobile). VP8/VP9 has failed miserably on this score. But Opus, the amazing new audio codec developed by Xiph/Mozilla/IETF/etc. in the manner suggested by the "Do's" is also notably absent from iOS and IE, (the latter of which could be considered particularly galling since it was co-developed with Microsoft subsidiary Skype).
Not that I think multiple approaches isn't a good thing, and you've got to sell what you're doing. It just seems a bit negative when Google has VP8 shipping on Android (and Android seems like the only mobile OS likely to ship Opus any time soon too).
- jallmann 12y agoThat slide was just noting factors that Daala would have to beware or overcome to succeed. While those certainly apply to VP8/VP9, Theora had many of the same problems. VP8 was always on tenuous ground both politically and technologically. VP9 is not in a better position, either. Xiph doesn't carry political baggage -- just a reputation for building solid codecs. Hopefully Xiph's re-thinking of codec design will pay dividends. The fact that Daala's design is coming from left-field is a real risk for adoption, but is nevertheless very welcome -- there has been only incremental progress since research into wavelet codecs in the '90s, and every single DCT-based codec in use today has been stuck in a local optimum since MPEG-1.
- astrange 12y agoWell, being DCT-based isn't that important, but they are all still block-based transforms. It doesn't help that all wavelet codecs have failed, because video researchers only test with PSNR and not with human subjects. H.264 doesn't use the DCT, but still uses the same size macroblocks, which is what made it unsuitable for very high-res video. HEVC uses up to 32x32 sized transforms.
- nullc 12y ago> H.264 doesn't use the DCT H264's transform is integer a DCT approximation— optimized to only use small multiplies and shifts—, some may say that its far enough that it ought not be called a DCT anymore, though at least after correcting for scaling I wouldn't agree. In any case, it shares DCT's advantages and disadvantages.
- zanny 12y agoThe thing is MS and Apple won't negotiate on any of this. They have never been involved with open standards and respectively pushed WMV and MOV formats instead. You have to move forward under the presumption that neither will ever cooperate in a macroscopic sense, especially after Google caved and gave up making youtube webm based. You still have to make the best solutions, and speak why they are the best, and hope everyone else will switch so that inevitably the dinosaurs do too. Because you can't reason with a trex.
- astrange 12y ago> They have never been involved with open standards and respectively pushed WMV and MOV formats instead. The MPEG-4 file format is .mov, and MPEG-4 onwards are open standards.
- patrickaljord 12y agoI'm pretty sure he meant patent free open standards or freely licensed patents open standards.
- astrange 12y agoAnd MPEG-4 Systems (the file format) is a patent-free open standard!
- ZeroGravitas 12y agoIs it? I thought it was just not actively monetized via licence and left as a gray area, like so many other things related to royalty-bearing codecs. A quick Google gives me this: http://www.mpegla.com/main/programs/M4S/Pages/Intro.aspx http://www.mpegla.com/main/programs/M4S/Pages/Intro.aspx
- magicalist 12y ago> especially after Google caved and gave up making youtube webm based They didn't remove h264 from Chrome, but when I watch videos on youtube, right click -> stats for nerds it lists the video as 'video/webm; codecs="vp9"'. That includes videos with ads, which didn't use to be the case.