3 ms·
It's tempting to say that these measures are pointless since, ultimately, the USG has the capability to access any data it wants. (After all they can send armed
by javajosh 12y ago
It's tempting to say that these measures are pointless since, ultimately, the USG has the capability to access any data it wants. (After all they can send armed men to get anything that you have access to.)
But actually, even imperfect, these measures by Google in particular are very useful and important, and are laudable. These measures stop the surreptitious acquisition of data, and so at least force data-acquisition activity into the open, and make it slightly more expensive to get.
Good! The US spy agencies are too reliant on technology! The bad guys can only really be found before they strike through face-to-face social interactions, which is inherently slow and doesn't scale. Good! Justice is a human problem and deserves to be executed at human scale. If it isn't then we risk a whole raft of moral hazards, which we are already seeing.
- enraged_camel 12y ago>>These measures stop the surreptitious acquisition of data, and so at least force data-acquisition activity into the open, and make it slightly more expensive to get. Too bad those expenses are ultimately paid for by the taxpayer.
- MichaelGG 12y agoIt's not just the USG that can do this. Anyone that can dig up some fibre and install equipment would have been able to tap these lines, as I understand. As far as the government relying on technology, I doubt that is a battle that can be won. Laws were written with inefficiency as an obvious countermeasure for abuse. Now that inefficiency is disappearing, the laws need to be revisited and countermeasures directly written in. This will be difficult. Google's roadblock is laudable and good, but perhaps a bit overdue. They were knowingly transmitting user data in plaintext outside of their physical control.
- fiber08 12y agoGoogle's roadblock is laudable and good, but perhaps a bit overdue. They were knowingly transmitting user data in plaintext outside of their physical control. I dunno about that. Imagine you're the engineer reviewing the design doc for the system that does cross-colo data transfers on company owned fiber. Do you really expect to see a detailed encryption system in there? Or even any discussion? I'm not sure I'd have said yes even now, much less a year ago. I may be a minority and sound hyperbolic in saying this, but in many ways Snowden feels like something of a "9/11" for our industry: innocent assumptions we made prior (the company-internal network is safe; no terrorist would go down with the plane) just aren't true anymore..
- rhizome 12y agoIf Snowden is 9/11 for "our industry," what does that say about Risen and Lichtblau's story describing NSA surveillance getting spiked by the NYTimes just before the 2004 elections, before eventually being allowed to be published over a year later? http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/16/politics/16program.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/16/politics/16program.html?pa... Those with innocent assumptions last year had their heads in the sand, and if we're talking about Google, Apple, et al, who claim to hire the best of the best, then that's a sad situation indeed. The simpler explanation is that it wasn't a problem to them until their customers found out.
- MichaelGG 12y agoThe AT&T fibre splitting thing was in 2006, Room 641a. So well before Snowden, it was known that fibre tapping was being done. The connection runs outside your control, why would you think it would be safe? Maybe they didn't think it likely, but the threat was always present and available for anyone with the desire and resources to exploit.