8 ms·
The Red Hourglass: Self-Experimentation with Black Widow Bites
- isaacdl 12y agoThis reminds me of Alexander Shulgin, who died a few days ago (there was an article here on HN [0]). Sometimes the most interesting and useful science is self-experimentation! [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7839226 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7839226
- jonah 12y ago> Forney later commented, "I do not recall having seen more abject pain manifested in any other medical or surgical condition." Yikes!
- danpat 12y agoThe world is full of stingy-bitey things that use chemicals rather than force, for example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irukandji_syndrome http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irukandji_syndrome Choice quotes: > most cases require intravenous opioid analgesia ... and > One unusual symptom associated with the syndrome is a feeling of "impending doom".[13] Patients have been reported as being so certain they are going to die, they beg their doctors to kill them to get it over with.
- lisper 12y agoOoh, it gets better: > On the television program Super Animal, a woman compared her pain from childbirth to her experience with Irukandji syndrome: "It's like when you're in labor, having a baby, and you've reached the peak of a contraction—that absolute peak—and you feel like you just can't do it anymore. That's the minimum that [Irukandji] pain is at, and it just builds from there."
- jfb 12y agoAny chance to link to the Schmidt Pain Scale[1]! 1.8 Bullhorn acacia ant: A rare, piercing, elevated sort of pain. Someone has fired a staple into your cheek. [1] http://scienceblogs.com/retrospectacle/2007/05/16/schmidt-pain-index-which-sting/ http://scienceblogs.com/retrospectacle/2007/05/16/schmidt-pa...
- jqm 12y agoThat was a great link. (from the comments which have no shortage of bug bite stories...) "The guy should have let one bug sting him on the back of each hand, then see which hand grabbed the other in pain. That way he could compare them semi-directly, sort of like the rock hardness scratch tests. That’d involve a lot of extra stings, but it’s for a good cause..."
- ams6110 12y agoThe symptoms as described in Wikipedia seem far less severe. He may have had either an abnormal sensitivity or received an unusually large dose of the venom. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latrodectism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latrodectism
- yread 12y ago> Blair let the spider bite him for ten seconds, I don't think people usually do that
- theviciousfish 12y agomasochism at its finest
- abelnation 12y agoNOPE
- softbuilder 12y agoThankfully the Black Widow is one of the dumbest spiders I've every encountered. Amazingly easy to kill if you can be calm about it. (I feel like I should be knocking on wood now.) I don't know how many varieties there are though, so YMMV.
- flatline 12y agoThe only time I've definitively seen one was in my kitchen. I put it in a Tupperware and let it loose in the yard. It was so slow moving that I was never particularly concerned about being bit. I had no idea the bite was that bad or I would have just finished it off instead.
- djcapelis 12y agoYeah these are one of the few spiders I kill on sight instead of gently moving to the yard. Pretty much as soon as I find one I immediately drop whatever I'm doing to make sure it's out of my living space as quickly as possible before I lose track of it.
- softbuilder 12y agoI lived for a few years in a particularly widow-prone area and had many black widows in the house and garage. I eventually realized that the daddy-long-legs variant in my house seemed to compete handily with them. So I stopped cleaning webs and found I had far fewer black widows. My house appeared rather shabby though. Tradeoffs.
- mikeash 12y agoFor some reason, your comment made me imagine a hacker forum filled with black widow spiders talking about stuff, and one of them posts, "Thankfully the human is one of the dumbest animals I've ever encountered. Amazingly easy to kill if you can be calm about it."
- lifeformed 12y agoIf you knock on wood, make sure it's not a pile of chopped wood outside.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- hvs 12y agoI think the modern definition of "cakewalk" was intended here that does not have the racial connotations [1]: an easy contest to win an easy task While the background on the word is interesting (I'll admit that I was unaware of it), the word does not have those racial connotations in conversation today. [1]http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/cakewalk http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/cakewalk
- ams6110 12y agoAt nearly 50 years of age, I have never before been aware of any defintion for "cakewalk" other than "easy task" and have never heard the word used in any context for which that definition didn't make sense. I don't see any value in trying to infer racial slurs where clearly none was intended. Focus on the real ones.
- pessimizer 12y agoThis entire conversation is bizarre. Just because something was done by black people doesn't give it 'racial connotations.' It's not a racial slur, or some cliche based on qualities ascribed to black people by white ones. It's something black people did, which rose to popularity (in exaggerated form) for a period of time amongst whites. I understand sometimes how navigating discussion about race feels like walking through a minefield to white people.
- kennywinker 12y agoAn interesting note: Cakewalk is a music software company that's been around since 1987. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cakewalk_(company) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cakewalk_(company)
- lisper 12y agoThat is interesting! I have recollections as a kid growing up in Kentucky in the early 70's of our elementary school holding cake walks as fund raisers. I was not aware of any racial overtones then, but it was Kentucky and I was young and staggeringly clueless.
- djcapelis 12y agoA friend of mine got bit by one once. She showed up in the hospital and calmly explained that she got bit by a black widow and asked for the anti venin. They looked at her skeptically until she pulled out a baggie with the dead widow in it. Then they treated her right away. If you find yourself bit, kill the spider and take it with you. You'll forestall any complaints and questions about whether you're sure it was a black widow and shorten the time to diagnose and begin treatment. (I.E. You'll experience far fewer of the symptoms the sooner you get treated.) (Unfortunately as of a few days ago, there is still a storage of supplies for the antivenin: http://www.ashp.org/menu/DrugShortages/CurrentShortages/bulletin.aspx?id=670 http://www.ashp.org/menu/DrugShortages/CurrentShortages/bull... So some hospitals may not have it in stock if they normally would. But apparently emergency supplies remain.)
- andrewflnr 12y agoI've just been bitten by a spider, and I'm supposed to calmly and quickly corner it, kill it, and scrape it into a baggie to show to the doctor? I'm supposed to do this after reading this article, knowing what's ahead of me?
- Natsu 12y agoSome people are more useful in emergencies than others. You're right that some will fall to pieces, but I'm the type with presence of mind and I would be doing that as quickly as I could rather than waiting until I caved in to the pain. Per the description, it's not that bad until the reaction spreads, so you want to take care of something like this before your feel like you're about to die.
- djcapelis 12y agoYou don't have to, but it would be a good idea. They'll eventually diagnose you and get around to tracking down some antivenin without it. If you lose track of it, it's probably more important to get to the hospital faster than trying to track it down. But if you can nab it, it'll save you time and you won't have to wonder where the spider went off to later, since many people encounter these things inside their homes.
- jfb 12y agoI was bitten by a brown recluse as a kid; I had a scar the size of a quarter on my leg from the skin necrosis. The only lasting effect was an acute arachnophobia.
- dwd 12y agoI was bitten by a brown house spider (Steatoda grossa) years ago and found the dead spider in my bed sheet. It left me feeling sick, unable to eat and struggling to drink for days due to the pain from my throat right through to my abdomen. Apparently the redback anti-venom works for it. Kill them on sight now along with the very rare redback or white-tail and lots of huntsman. We also get a few black house spiders which I generally leave unless they are moving about. As mentioned in another comment nothing beats an irukandji for pain. It also has an interesting story of self-experimentation to pin down the jellyfish as the cause of Irukandji Syndrome: http://lifeinthefastlane.com/jack-barnes-and-the-irukandji-enigma/ http://lifeinthefastlane.com/jack-barnes-and-the-irukandji-e...
- jfb 12y agoI have no idea how you people survive to adulthood.
- dwd 12y agoHa, and I didn't even mention the snakes... You can do certain things to minimise your risk of getting bitten, or not. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wynx1ukwdVA&feature=kp https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wynx1ukwdVA&feature=kp
- snowwindwaves 12y agoI had two friends bitten by brown recluse. One was sick for days and his knee swelled up like a Mellon and the other didn't fare much better.
- jqm 12y agoNuts. I would have probably stuck with lab rats. I was bit by a brown recluse as a kid. The symptoms were nothing like this but it did create a large nasty looking hole in my calf that seemed to grow for a couple of weeks rotting the flesh. It was unpleasant but not all that painful considering. In addition to the recluse bite, I have been stung by bees, wasps, jellyfish and a scorpion but the worst was from nothing less than a caterpillar. It happened twice... two different kinds of caterpillars (the first one I put my hand on climbing a tree, the second I actually picked up). It was not to the level described in the article, but some of the same type symptoms appeared. My arm ached with horrible muscle pains, I felt symptoms throughout my body and I felt extremely ill for a day or so. I was around 10 or 12 at the time, we had just moved to Florida and I was quite surprised to learn that some caterpillars stung. I don't live there anymore but am still extremely wary of caterpillars that have any fuzz or hair.
- plink 12y agoSo, because the old African-American entertainment of a cakewalk never gained the same eminence earned (deservedly) by jazz or tap, then it is to be considered racist and on par with a slur? The discussion over this matter seems itself to be an entertainment and a craven one.
- jqm 12y agoDisclaimer: My piece had nothing to do with race nor cakewalks, I have no idea what they have to do with anything, and you are replying to a deleted comment below....
- plink 12y agoNo kidding. I couldn't very well post to a deleted comment. In that matter I apologize to you. It was sort of like flyswatting a hologram.
- mc_hammer 12y agoweird - i got the same thing from a catapiller - i had no idea this was really a thing!
- hornbaker 12y agoIf you like stories like this, don't miss the one of the veterinarian who infested himself with cat ear mites and documented the results: http://kimberlymoynahan.com/2012/10/of-mites-and-men/ http://kimberlymoynahan.com/2012/10/of-mites-and-men/
- nkurz 12y agoIf anyone has access to the 1934 paper Blair wrote about this, I'd love to read it. My address is in my HN profile. SPIDER POISONING: EXPERIMENTAL STUDY OF THE EFFECTS OF THE BITE OF THE FEMALE LATRODECTUS MACTANS IN MAN A. W. BLAIR, M.D. Arch Intern Med (Chic). 1934;54(6):831-843. doi:10.1001/archinte.1934.00160180003001.
- mikexstudios 12y agoGreat find! Here you go: https://mega.co.nz/#!bcUjRZoB!2nZjyURearxqO-0DDxUA57UnzEa1jhtVp2Uw7F7IMhU https://mega.co.nz/#!bcUjRZoB!2nZjyURearxqO-0DDxUA57UnzEa1jh...
- csours 12y agoA link to Mega... Great now people will think we're hackers.
- srean 12y agoWhat amazes me is the question: what kind of evolutionary pressure would drive creatures to develop stings and venom this viscious. I would have thought nature would stop optimizing once a sting is a good enough deterrent. It is as if someone said, no, I would optimize the crap out of this chemical weapon. I have always been intrigued by how much does the effect generalize across the victim species. Consider tarantula wasps, their sting take pain and suffering to new heights (for humans). But really what the wasps use it for, primarily, is to temporarily immobilize a tarantula so that it can lay eggs on it. The hatchlings end up eating the tarantula. If temporary immobilization is the main use case (surely not the only use case), must it be this painful. Is the tarantula in as much pain and if so what purpose is that serving ? It seems something that gives them a pleasure trip makes more sense.
- aylons 12y agoA few layman hypothesis: * A more powerful venom will work faster and more reliably. * This is not only a very powerful, but also a very efficient venom. More efficient venom reduces manufacturing costs (as only a few molecules are needed). * Chance probably have played a role here. Black widows hardly had any pressure to evolve a specific venom against humans. As our nerve system is based on the same basic molecules as every other land creature, but not the same structure, a venom that is good enough to kill a mouse may have a devastating (albeit non-fatal) effect on us. I'm already speculating, so I may be cruel: maybe the spider wants to paralyze the mouse, but keep him alive for a few days so the flesh stays fresh as they eat it.
- aptwebapps 12y ago"I'm already speculating, so I may be cruel: maybe the spider wants to paralyze the mouse, but keep him alive for a few days so the flesh stays fresh as they eat it." Another layman here, but I believe spider venom is designed to pre-digest food to some extent, rather than to keep it fresh.
- ArkyBeagle 12y agoSnake venom of the rattlesnake variety certainly is; the fangs are the first line of the digestive system. Black mamba venom is a neurotoxin. It's remarkable how diverse venom is.
- farmfood 12y agoMy 6 yr-old daughter asked me to get rid of a spider from her room. In I went with a "ho ho ho, of course dear" fatherly attitude to find a mature female Black Widow sat on the rocker switch of her bedside lamp. I calmly asked my little girl to go fetch her mother.
- karmajunkie 12y agoI know the feeling. Once last year my four year old refused to go to sleep, yelling about monsters in his room. Somewhat exasperated, I went into his room and turned on the light to find the biggest scorpion I'd ever seen crawling up his wall. I had a hell of a time arguing with him when he got convinced about monsters lurking for six months afterwards. Wasn't sad to move out of that apartment.
- Htsthbjig 12y agoBig scorpions are not dangerous. The most dangerous scorpions tend to be smaller ones. This I leaned from Sahara desert natives. I found a small one under a rock and played with it. Those people got crazy at me.
- cc439 12y ago" A dose of the venom contains only a few molecules of the neurotoxin, which has a high molecular weight--in fact, the molecules are large enough to be seen under an ordinary microscope." Does anyone have another source for this, maybe a photo? I spent some time looking around but I can't find anything relevant and it seems a little hard to believe.
- dwhly 12y agoUnless the molecular weight is about 10 pentillion (?) you ain't gonna see diddly! Avogadro's number is a big thing. (6 x 10^23). Now agreed that you don't need a mole of something (especially w/ a high molecular weight) to be able to see it in a microscope. But it's probably at least w/in 4 to 5 orders of magnitude of the right number.
- chc 12y agoIf you mean 10^18, it's a quintillion.
- drjesusphd 12y agoDNA is a molecule, and under the right conditions, you can see it under a microscope as chromosomes.
- ealloc 12y agoIt's wrong, the molecules are many orders of magnitude smaller than is possible to see. The main black widow venom is alpha-Latrotoxin (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latrotoxin http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latrotoxin), which is a 130 kDa protein according to wikipedia. That's large for a protein but there are bigger. Eukaryotic ribosomes are around 2500 kDa, but even they are completely invisible at 20 nm wide, and there are a thousands-millions of them per cell.
- derefr 12y ago> The toxin somehow flips a switch that activates a self-torture mechanism. Anyone have a clearer explanation for the psychopharmacology at work here?
- Friedduck 12y agoI had a great aunt die from a bite by a Brown Recluse. All this did was solidify my fear of spiders in general. What I remember of it (I was young when this happened) was that the bite was misdiagnosed initially as nothing serious and she was sent home with a topical ointment. Things went downhill fast. I know that the limb that was bitten was amputated, and that by the time they figured out the cause her fate was sealed. I know they're supposed to be beneficial insects but I kill just about every one I encounter to this day. At least the Black Widow is distinctive. It's unmistakable if you see one.
- pjungwir 12y agoWhen I lived in southern California, black widows were pretty common. A few tips: - They like to hang out in wood piles or corners of the garage. - Their webs look "messy". Also the webs are pretty tough and don't tear easily. You can pluck them like guitar strings.
- aaronem 12y agoMore generally, they like dark, cool places where they aren't likely to be disturbed. For a few years in my childhood, my mother and I shared a small house with a widow who'd set up housekeeping between the toilet tank and the wall; we got along fine, no doubt as much due to her ability to keep well fed in an old and not well constructed rural home, as to the respect we were careful to maintain in our dealings with her.
- girvo 12y agoI've been bitten by a Redback Spider (related to the Black Widow, I believe), twice! As a kid I was fascinated by insects and spiders, and used to love watching them for hours. As it turns out, Redbacks hurt a lot, its one of the worst bites I've experienced. A sharp sensation, followed by a burning and prickliness. Horrible. Parents took me to the hospital straight away, as it made me feel really sick (I was 10 years old the first time, and 11 the second). After the second time I sort of learned my lesson...
- ZenPro 12y agoThis thread, more than any other, illustrates why the majority of posters should be ignored. Approximately 50% of the posts are preceded with a variation of - "I am just speculating but..." Why on earth would 99.9% of the people on this thread think they have the expertise to offer an opinion of the evolution of arachnid venom is beyond me. Fascinating article, even more fascinating watching humans debate like blind people in the dark.
- dm2 12y agoBrown Recluse spiders are very common where I live and I've known countless people who have been bitten by them and ended up with a necrosis wound. Unfortunately the Brown Recluse spider looks very similar to many harmless spiders, so if there is a brown spider I usually don't take any chances unless I can positively identify it. Supposedly Black Widows are in my area also, but I've never seen one. I do let these guys stay in my house most of the time: http://www.spiders.us/species/pholcus-phalangioides/ http://www.spiders.us/species/pholcus-phalangioides/ I'm not sure how I feel about this though: http://www.spiders.us/files/pholcus-phalangioides-5.jpg http://www.spiders.us/files/pholcus-phalangioides-5.jpg Spiders don't creep me out at all, but a large group of spiders would, even though I've heard that their fangs cannot pierce human skin. BTW, changing the original articles main layout table (15 year old site I'm guessing) to 1800px makes the article much more readable. I found it hard to read the 270px wide article with 1 foot of white space on each side.