3 ms·
Stop with the down-votes, you guys. Had there been no references cited by chirsBob, this comment would be an overall negative "hearsay"-type contribution, but
by DenisM 12y ago
Stop with the down-votes, you guys.
Had there been no references cited by chirsBob, this comment would be an overall negative "hearsay"-type contribution, but the inclusion of a reasonably reputable, if outdated, reference allowed others to point out the paper retraction, and raised the overall quality of the discussion.
- chrisBob 12y agoNo, actually I submitted it knowing that the paper had been retracted, and was stirring up trouble. The down votes are perfectly reasonable in this case. I do appreciate the defense though as some times is is hard to tell which posts were inaccurate by mistakes, and which were malicious. [edited to thank the defending post]