14 ms·
There is still a moral question of killing civillians versus killing volunteer soldiers versus killing conscripted soldiers. Then you need to remember there we
by aidenn0 12y ago
There is still a moral question of killing civillians versus killing volunteer soldiers versus killing conscripted soldiers.
Then you need to remember there were two bombings of Japan. Was the second one necessary to prevent a land invasion of Japan? Furthermore it seems likely that a combined soviet/american land invasion would have prompted nearly as quick of a surrender as the atomic bombings.
Of course we can play these "what-if" games all day; the people at the time needed to make a decision, and I don't think it was all that bad of a decision with the information they had.
When the use of deadly force is appropriate is the biggest open question in ethics IMO.
- mpyne 12y ago> Furthermore it seems likely that a combined soviet/american land invasion would have prompted nearly as quick of a surrender as the atomic bombings. Perhaps (there always remains the question of where the Soviets would have found the needed amphibious shipping to make it happen, of course). But even if we assume it happens, now we have another Korea split into a Communist and non-Communist bloc. Great improvement, no? You're right about what-if games though... I'm just glad the decision wasn't mine to have to make, especially with those ethical questions still not fully settled even to this day.
- katbyte 12y agoBefore the atomic bombs were dropped, thousands of conventional bombs were dropped on Tokyo. For example in one night 1700 bombs were dropped on Tokyo killing 100,000 in what some call the "the single deadliest air raid of World War II" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo
- cam_l 12y agoFrom your link: "Curtis LeMay ordered the bombers to drop incendiary bombs to burn Japan's vulnerable wood-and-paper buildings." Not just conventional bombs, they deliberately burned a hundred thousand innocent people to death. Not nearly enough people know about this atrocity, especially in relation to Hiroshima and Nagasaki.