4 ms·
I can't figure out what would be providing more CO2. The container is near full of greenery; where does it get air exchange? Maybe the cork leaks just enough
by CapitalistCartr 12y ago
I can't figure out what would be providing more CO2. The container is near full of greenery; where does it get air exchange? Maybe the cork leaks just enough is all I can figure.
- minikites 12y agoExactly, where is the plant mass coming from? Can bacteria break soil down into carbon that the plant can use to build more leaves/stems/roots?
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoThe Daily Fail version claims so, but that doesn't seem sufficient. Nonetheless, its clearly working. It'd be interesting to insert a probe through the cork and run a real-time analysis of the air composition.
- minikites 12y agoHmm. So over time the soil mass will decrease into nothing as the plant expands?
- kordless 12y agoBits of the plant are going to decay back into soil.
- saalweachter 12y agoMost of the mass of plants comes from the atmosphere, not the soil. 95%+ of a given plant is oxygen, hydrogen, and carbon. The soil provides trace elements and a place from which to absorb water.
- darkxanthos 12y agoI don't think we can say it's clearly working... This seems like an extraordinary claim and it's hard to know if there's any truth fudging.
- droopyEyelids 12y agoAnother puzzling factor is the clarity of the glass. When I've seen bottle gardens, they all develop a thick scum from minerals in condensation, algae, and bacterial plaques.
- gnufied 12y agoThere is also, Cellular respiration in night within the plant itself, which release some CO2 in the atmosphere. So may be combined with CO2 released by Bacteria and Cellular respiration in plant, it can survive.
- zhemao 12y agoAerobic bacteria takes in oxygen and produces CO2 in the same way that animals do.
- quodestabsurdum 12y agoThe container was last watered twelve years after it was planted. Twelve years is plenty of time for most plants (especially something many people would consider a weed) to reach that size. At this point it's simply in maintenance mode - similar to a bonsai which never requires trimming.
- ahi 12y agoBacteria in the soil. One of the reasons Biosphere 2 fell apart.
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoI can't see how decaying plant matter would provide enough CO2 to keep the larger greenery healthy. Perhaps the original soil had an exceptional amount, but it would take time for it to break down; plants can empty a container such as that of CO2 in a day or so.
- comboy 12y agoIsn't it how the world worked before animals evolved? Or is there some yet another source of CO2?
- seszett 12y agoFungus produces CO2 from plant tissues as well, so they are probably an important component of this ecosystem.
- matt-attack 12y agoDid you just imply Fungi are plants?
- seszett 12y agoHuh... no, what would make you think that?
- gillier 12y agoThe world has a much lower plant:world ratio than that bottle does.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 12y ago
- harty65 12y agoFrom a related article: "But the eco-system also uses cellular respiration to break down decaying material shed by the plant. In this part of the process, bacteria inside the soil of the bottle garden absorbs the plant's waste oxygen and releasing carbon dioxide which the growing plant can reuse."
- mathattack 12y agoWas this a planned hack, or does this naturally occur? My first thought was also, "Where does the CO2 come from?" I suspect this is a very fine balance - if you're off by just a little, one or the other would die. There's not much room for error in a jar.
- windsurfer 12y agoMost bacteria and plants can survive in a huge range of CO2 and O2 concentrations. Humans are the ones that cannot.
- duaneb 12y ago> I suspect this is a very fine balance - if you're off by just a little, one or the other would die. This is an illusion; it's a dialectic between the two. Problems lead to a shift in balance, not a death.
- gwern 12y ago> There's not much room for error in a jar. Article mentions that most of the jars failed.
- runeks 12y ago> I suspect this is a very fine balance - if you're off by just a little, one or the other would die. There's not much room for error in a jar. Why would all bacteria die if there is less oxygen? I imagine the weakest bacteria would die, thereby increasing the amount of O2 per bacteria, and thus reaching equilibrium again.
- digitalsushi 12y agoPlants suck in CO2 when they are storing energy, but when they spend their energy they make CO2 just like us. Plants have a respiration process just like animals. They just tend to remove more CO2 than they put out (until they get burned/turn into coal, oil, etc)
- gillier 12y agoRight, but when plants grow, they are net CO2 absorbers -- that's what photosynthesis and carbon offsets and "planting trees" is all about. There's a lot of carbon in those plants -- did it all come CO2 from the original supply in the bottle?
- duaneb 12y agoProbably root fungus and bacteria symbiosis. These have been made in biology classes for decades, this is just a particularly massive example.
- kteofanidis 12y agoFrom what I understand the container was sealed 11 years after the initial planting. I guess all the carbon entered from the atmosphere before the final watering in 1972. The total biomass must have remained roughly constant since.