4 ms·
"Illegitimate"? It's certainly illegal, but there is a very open question about whether it should be legal, and I would say that archiving, organizing and maki
by rwmj 12y ago
"Illegitimate"? It's certainly illegal, but there is a very open question about whether it should be legal, and I would say that archiving, organizing and making freely available software that has no/little commercial value is a legitimate activity.
Other types of intellectual property can be abandoned, so why not copyright? Patents are ineffective unless the owner actively enforces their rights by suing infringers. And trademarks are abandoned simply by not being used[1].
So why not let copyright lapse unless the owner regularly files for renewal, perhaps with a small fee attached to discourage auto-renewal.
[1] http://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/abandonment_of_trademark http://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/abandonment_of_trademark
- ekianjo 12y ago> perhaps with a small fee attached to discourage auto-renewal. If it's a small fee, you can be sure that all large companies will enforce their copyrights forever (and Disney even continue to enforce copyrights that should have expired).
- icebraining 12y agoNobody said the copyright holders should be allowed to renew indefinitely.
- Nursie 12y agoI'm pretty sure you're wrong about patents, I think that the non-enforcement thing relates to trademarks as well. Still, I don't disagree, I think an abandonware archive is a good thing. I always loved that Home Of The Underdogs (for example) existed, so I could get hold of old DOS games I used to own in the 80s but have long since lost.
- _delirium 12y agoOne doesn't lose a patent for non-enforcement (though it's possible equitable doctrines like laches could complicate future suits after a period of non-enforcement). However patents do require frequent explicit renewal, like copyright used to: maintenance fees have to be paid at 3.5, 7.5, and 11.5 years after the patent is granted, or it expires early.
- Fuxy 12y agoThis is just a though but how cool would it be if after 20 years of copyright you would be required to pay a small fee that would grow exponentially and is required to be payed every 5 years. If a corporation values its copyright that much their going to pay if it's not that valuable they won't bother to keep it. That would certainly eliminate useless renewal.
- zokier 12y agoThat would be even worse than the current system. At least now the system is equal to everyone, from starving artists and foss hackers to billion dollar corporations like Disney and MS.