3 ms·
You are part of a problem. I can't say this strongly enough. Some people have tickets to sell, others would like to go to the event. You would interpose yourse
by Nursie 12y ago
You are part of a problem. I can't say this strongly enough.
Some people have tickets to sell, others would like to go to the event. You would interpose yourself to suck money out of the latter group while providing no service.
You're making the world a worse place.
- ghshephard 12y agoWell, he's actually making the world a much better place for people with money who wish to go to these events, but don't have the time to wait in line for tickets. Normally, for events that are "underpriced" people with more time than money can attend events that people with more money than time can't. You are making a value judgement that people with time should be allowed to go to events, but people with money should not. That's fine for you to do, but I don't think you can make a global statement that people who enable this opportunity for people with more money than time are making the world a "worse place".
- Nursie 12y agoNo, I'm making a judgement that he is inserting himself into the process to extract money, while providing no value, and making the world a worse place. He is not enabling, he is disabling and profiteering, it's incredibly antisocial.
- ghshephard 12y agoWell, as one who buys most of his tickets from StubHub, I certainly appreciate the opportunities to see events that I would otherwise never have gotten to have experienced. My life has been enriched, and I personally really appreciate that people and services like this exist - I certainly get a great deal of value from them. I'm not sure what's upsetting you so much. And, honestly, there is a big difference (at least to me) between someone making concert, sport, or event tickets available at a markup, (which, btw, is a pretty common Broadway system these days for plays, done by the theater themselves no third party required) - and buying up all the water after a disaster and selling it at a markup - I would consider that behavior to be anti-social and profiteering. Leisure activities are entirely optional. Making them available to people who want to see them, and can pay for them, seems to be a positive thing to me.
- Nursie 12y agoWhen it's done competetively with people who want to go to an event, when people like him swoop in and deny them tickets, that's what gets me. Oh? Wanted to go see that band you like did you? Waiting online when the tickets went on sale were we? Too bad, I got them first. I don't even want to go but now you're going to have to pay me twice the face value or you're SOL. That's what's antisocial and wrong about it. And that's why there are now so many situations where event promoters are actively fighting against it.
- ghshephard 12y agoIf they are charging more for the tickets than you think the band is worth - just don't buy them. By definition, the people who will be going to that concert think that they are worth that much. What's pissing you off, is that prior to ticket brokers, you were able to buy tickets at a lower price than you thought the concert was worth - and now the brokers are making at market at the accurate price, depriving you of the discount. Event Promoters are pissed off, because they aren't getting their cut of the $$$. You are pissed off because you are paying more $$$ than you would have. I understand why both of you are pissed off - but don't making global statements like, "Ticket brokers are making the world a worse place" without recognizing that they are also making it a better place at the same time.
- Nursie 12y agoThey are inserting themselves where they aren't wanted and either extracting cash or denying people the opportunity to attend. I'm sorry for you that you can't see how incredibly antisocial this is.
- ghshephard 12y agoIf they weren't wanted, then people wouldn't be purchasing tickets. Ticket Brokers exist because the tickets are being sold for less than what people believe they are worth. That's an economic activity, not a social one. We aren't talking about food, water, or gas in a disaster here - we're talking about luxury items. If the tickets were sold at the clearing price, then ticket brokers would not exist. I'm honestly curious - do you find Broadway's latest trend towards "variable pricing" anti-social? From the perspective of the customer, they are doing exactly what the broker's are doing - marking up the tickets to the highest possible price they can get on a per-seat basis - sometimes marking tickets up 2x to 3x what they used to be. Obviously the producer's are happy with this - because they are now collecting the $$$ themselves. But, from the perspective of a customer - prices are now jacked up to what the market will bear. I'm interested in your perspective - is the broker "anti-social" because they are depriving the producer of money, or because they are jacking up the prices of tickets to a level that the lower-income fan can't afford?
- rayiner 12y agoThis fallacy is in a nutshell why people are irrationally mad about HFT. He's providing liquidity to the market for the tickets. Think about it: if he can come along and sell the tickets for a markup, why won't the sellers sell directly to the buyers and capture that whole amount for themselves? The reason is that they want to unload the ticket quickly and with less hassle, and finding that high-bidding buyer takes more time than finding the scalper. Similarly, why doesn't the buyer seek out a seller himself? Because it takes more time. Otherwise, both would be irrational to interact with him rather than directly. By interposing himself in the transaction, he makes the process easier and quicker for both buyer and seller, and that provided value.
- Nursie 12y ago>> why won't the sellers sell directly to the buyers and capture that whole amount for themselves? Oh I don't know, because they want ordinary people without huge fat wallets to get a chance to go along? >> The reason is that they want to unload the ticket quickly and with less hassle, and finding that high-bidding buyer takes more time than finding the scalper. Not really, you could very easily set up a website that would do this stuff for the whole industry and cut out the scalpers. The only reason I can think that this isn't common is because people find it distasteful. >> Similarly, why doesn't the buyer seek out a seller himself? He often does, just to find some arsehole has interposed himself and is holding a serious proportion of total tickets to ransom. >> By interposing himself in the transaction, he makes the process easier and quicker for both buyer and seller, and that provided value. Utter bullshit. Sorry, but it's just nonsense. He inconveniences ticket buyers by holding back tickets they would have bought until he gets paid off. There is no value in what he does. It's unacceptable.
- rayiner 12y ago> Oh I don't know, because they want ordinary people without huge fat wallets to get a chance to go along? Oh please. I need to bail on some awesome event because my girlfriend broke up with me or work dropped some unmanageable project on my lap. I don't care who gets the ticket, I just want to get rid of it quickly. > Not really, you could very easily set up a website that would do this stuff for the whole industry and cut out the scalpers. It's called EBay, and they haven't replaced the scalpers. Its because scalpers take advantage of a temporal lag between supply and demand. The guy canceling wants his money now. The guy with deep pockets can't be bothered to go looking until the last minute. > He often does, just to find some arsehole has interposed himself and is holding a serious proportion of total tickets to ransom. Why did the scalper get there first? Because the seller wanted to unload quickly and the buyer didn't think about it until later. Again, if the buyers were there when the sellers were selling, nobody would sell to scalpers. But the buyers aren't there. Without scalpers, the sellers would have to hold on to the tickets longer.
- tptacek 12y agoThere is no place for this kind of comment on HN. You could just as easily have written this without personalizing it; it still wouldn't be a great HN comment (picking a fight over ticket scalping on a thread about Alinea is impolite), but it wouldn't be an awful comment. This, on the other hand, is an awful comment.
- Nursie 12y agoSorry, someone says proudly how they instigate a practice I find pretty awful and would like to apply their behaviour to yet another market, and I'm supposed to not comment on it or make it personal? Whatever.
- tptacek 12y agoYes, you are partially correct: you are not supposed to make things personal.
- dkrich 12y agoTo directly address your point and why I disagree- what we're really talking about here is the economics concept of consumer surplus. What the OP was eluding to (and he's correct) is the fact that if demand is such that tickets are selling out and people who want tickets are presumably waiting to get them for a later date, then that's a strong signal that there is a large amount of uncaptured consumer surplus. In other words, consumers are taking a profit of value from the restaurant because they are getting tickets for less money than they would have otherwise paid. To think about the problem differently- occasionally you will come to certain places and see two Starbucks sitting across the street from each other. If you ever wondered why that is, the reason is that in certain locations, demand is so high at peak times that the lines will get so long that large numbers of customers will actually not buy coffee because they aren't willing to wait. Rather than raise prices during these times, Starbucks figured out that it was profitable to open a second adjacent location to service this demand overflow. I don't mean to sound condescending, but there are two sides to this coin and I think that looking at it from only the customer side is a mistake. The restaurant is losing out on potential profits that the customers are capturing. Traders would simply be capturing the surplus that the restaurant can't or won't. It isn't necessarily being greedy, it's just being smart.