6 ms·
Virginia orders Uber, Lyft to stop operating in state
- Haul4ss 12y agoRent seeking, baby! Gotta protect the entrenched interests.
- tswartz 12y ago>> the DMV urged riders to make informed choices about which transportation services they use. The DMV says riders should check that cars have seatbelts, current license plate and inspection stickers. Amazed at the reasons they point to in an attempt to justify their actions. In all my encounters with Lyft and Uber the cars conditions are well above a taxi. A typical taxi ride includes squealing brakes and bottoming out due to suspension falling apart.
- thenmar 12y agoNot that I disagree, but it's not like you'd notice if a car hadn't been inspected for years and had a non-functioning airbag. At least not until you needed it.
- mikeash 12y agoYou would in Virginia, since yearly inspections are required and the sticker is displayed prominently in the windshield.
- tswartz 12y agoThat is certainly a good point. Now, I'm curious how often and comprehensive a taxi inspection really is.
- enraged_camel 12y agoYes, but run-down cars with squealing brakes and bad suspensions are much more likely to also not have a functioning airbag.
- Xorlev 12y agoCan't compete? Lobby.
- pdq 12y agoIt's pretty ridiculous that car-pooling (aka ride-sharing) is fully legal and unrestricted. However, the second you charge money for the same service, the regulators want to get involved to check for safety, inspections, and licensing.
- calbear81 12y agoYes, a commercial relationship changes the nature of that transaction since commercial transactions are regulated/taxed in many states.
- pdq 12y agoYou're missing the point. If the grounds are that ethically paying customers should have taxis licensed, why do those ethics not apply also to donated services, like car-pooling?
- rtpg 12y agoBecause in the donated service (car pooling) its much less likely that the people participating are doing so as members of the public. Its like the difference between me showing a movie in my house to 15 friends And me renting out a movie theatre and opening the doors for everyone to come in. Even if the same 15 friends show up, they do it as members of the public.
- ertdfgcb 12y agoBecause if there is money involved there is incentive to do it for a living, which leads to incentive to cut costs and that might not always be done in a consumer-friendly way; therefore regulation is needed. If there is no money involved, the people who would cut costs and make it unsafe for the consumer are rarer -- since they can't do it for a living, and the relationship is harder to regulate since the only thing involved is communication between two parties, so it's probably not worth it.
- mikeash 12y agoI'm pretty sure he sees the point you're making, but disagrees with it. While your question, which is already answered in the post you're replying to, indicates to me that you're missing the point.
- john_b 12y ago> ""I urge the citizens of Virginia to protect their families by using only companies that appear on DMV's website as licensed transportation services. If it's not on the list, it's not recommended," says DMV Commissioner Richard Holcomb." "Save the children!" plus an appeal to authority. If your argument has no substance, you might as well go full fallacy.
- lectrick 12y agoThe biggest startup challenge seems to be to deal with existing laws (and people, and relationships) that never imagined your brand new idea. The technological challenge seems secondary.
- trhway 12y ago>"As many of the current regulations surrounding taxis and limos were created before anything like Lyft's peer-to-peer model was ever imagined it wasn't that the peer-to-peer model wasn't imagined, it just that the "peer-to-peer" transportation services have been illegal pretty much everywhere. What was changed by Lyft and the likes is the number of "law-breakers", i.e. it seems it reached critical threshold for [considering] regulations change. Laws/regulations is just a written record of the power balance, and as the balance has just somewhat shifted it thus prompted the changes in the written record of it.
- DigitalSea 12y agoWon't somebody please think of the children and the broken taxi industry! Before Uber and Lyft hit the scene, you only had a small pool to pick your taxi from only to discover all major taxi companies are in cahoots together anyway. Uber to me is reliable, it's cheaper and it's safer. I couldn't count the number of times I've ordered a taxi that just didn't show up (presumably they took a more profitable fare elsewhere), rude drivers, drivers that speed without any kind of accountability. You complain to the taxi company and they couldn't really care less. Instead of embracing change, taxi companies are clinging to their lobbyist and broken ways. Look how well that turned out for the music industry when they tried to fight digital music and streaming... It's the same situation happening all over again. Uber and Lyft will eventually win, it's only a matter of time.
- SDGT 12y agoAgree, it's like life is a constant game of "maintain the status quo", and we measure innovation by how pissed people get that had already invested in said status quo. I just called Time Warner yesterday to complain until they gave me better pricing and ended up arguing with the retention guy about how it would cost them less if they just killed their analog output (which still runs in my area) and gave internet users the BW. TWC is finally doing so in the area, but not after milking every last drop out of the aging analog cable crowd. >You complain to the taxi company and they could care less ...twitch... couldn't care less
- droopyEyelids 12y agoThere are many different municipalities with many different qualities of taxi service. And there are many different laws affecting who can operate taxi services in those areas. I don't know how things were in Virginia, but in Chicago regular taxis are vastly better than uberx/lyft in every way except price. Also, taxi drivers are required to have a chauffeur's license that tests them for TB along with city knowledge. Uber works well for you and many of us. But don't portray this as a hero's fight against a broken industry when in reality it's a nuanced decision and there are valid points of view on both sides of the argument.
- 12y ago
- hashtags 12y agoWhen you see that trading is done, not by consent, but by compulsion- When you see that in order to produce, you need to obtain permission from men who produce nothing- when you see that money is flowing to those who deal, not in goods, but in favors- when you see that men get richer by graft and by pull than by work, and your laws don’t protect you against them, but protect them against you- when you see corruption being rewarded and honesty becoming a self-sacrifice- you may know that your society is doomed. -Francisco D'Anconia
- ortuna 12y agoThese "licensed" services get out of hand where allowed number of licenses are far lower than demand. This turns into a huge mess as a recent but less publicized account shows: http://www.fbi.gov/washingtondc/press-releases/2013/former-general-manager-sentenced-in-taxi-bribery-scheme http://www.fbi.gov/washingtondc/press-releases/2013/former-g...
- Nursie 12y agoI'm sorry, I know there's a religion of disruption going on around these parts, and I know that there's disdain for established business, and regulations that seem to keep new players out of the market, and unnecessary bureaucracy and all of these things... But sometimes, just sometimes some of the regulations and restrictions are legitimate consumer protection mechanisms that benefit all of us, and we should think before we throw them out in the name of progress.
- zibit 12y agoSometimes, but not this time
- potatolicious 12y agoAgreed. There is a nuance to this that is frequently forgotten in tech circles, where the government is pure evil and unrestricted free enterprise is the definition of what is right and good. That said, it's too bad that the two sides represent the extremes and there is no entity representing the sane middle ground. On the one hand you have an entrenched industry resistant to any form of change (and not willing to abuse politics to do this), on the other hand you have companies that laugh in the face of decades of learned consumer experience and have a history of abusing the market to push out competitors (see: Uber and the call-and-cancel-against-competitors debacle). I'm for more taxis on roads. I'm for more technology in taxis. I'm for transparent payments and real enforcement against bad drivers (and bad passengers!). I'm also for proper licensing, proper insurance, consumer protections (e.g., being kicked out of a cab for a surge pricing fare), and trustworthy metering. I suspect most people are in this middle ground, but no one represents us. I don't want Uber to the arbiter what goes forward, and I don't want the taxi lobby either. Both scenarios are distinctly dystopian.
- kyrra 12y agoThe issue most cities and states are running into is that the laws that protect the current cab industry are making it near impossible for more cabs to be added. There are years long waiting lines for new licenses because they give out so few. And in those cities there are long waits to get a cab. Uber and Lyft are able to get traction because the government is being too slow to meet the demands people have within their cities/states. Regulation is good for consumer protection, but when it's preventing services to reach consumers, there is a problem. These companies are willing to go around the laws cause the government is not doing their job.
- zibit 12y agoFolks at Uber, how best should I protest this?
- logn 12y agoI don't get people's sentiment. We should either follow laws or change them. Simply deciding we don't enforce certain laws or reinterpreting according to various interests leads to worse situations. If Uber and Lyft want to break the law, ok, but how can you blame the DMV for enforcing it?
- zibit 12y agoLet me give all the non Virginians a quick glimpse into how unfair this is. DC has a thing called slug lines. Traffic is so bad here that drivers will offer strangers a ride so they can get on the HOV lanes. Lots of people do this. There are lines all over DC and Virginia of people doing this. Does the Virginia DMV say anything about slug lines and how unsafe they may be? Or how the drivers may or may not have training? Or how the cars may not have been properly inspected? NO, in fact they encourage it (see below) Why? cause it doesn't disrupt the powers that be They actually link to slug lines - again a popular practice of allowing strangers into the car of another stranger - on this page: http://www.virginiadot.org/travel/hov-rulesfaq.asp http://www.virginiadot.org/travel/hov-rulesfaq.asp
- JPKab 12y agoSee my comment in this thread about me Ubering to DCA on Friday, and now when I get back in tomorrow I won't have it. But just want to point out: Because nobody is being paid in slug lines, they couldn't tell people not to do it even if they wanted to. You make an excellent point about how they claim to care about safety and then tell people to go use slug lines. For a good laugh, go look at the slug line horror stories. My favorite is a guy who got in a car with a woman who was pulled over minutes later with a suspended license and warrants. She was carted off to jail, and the police officers gave him a ride to a strip mall where he had to call a taxi.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ddp 12y agoShould we shave off a Billion now?