3 ms·
Guilt Your Children Well? The importance of guilt in child rearing
- zargon 17y agoFrom comment #7 (R.K.) "Guilt naturally morphs into resentment... What works? Parents in therapy. This will help a lot."
- Ixiaus 17y agoA silly convention in my opinion. Children only need to be reared because the parents often times do not live by their own principles and ethics (nobody is perfect, I do understand this, I mean it in the majority of life experiences). Children learn by example - punishment, guilt, anything on the end of the stick that trains the child into feeling bad and conforming to someone else's wishes is archaic and stagnates social evolution. On that same note though, free will is free will - I just focus on my beliefs, principles, and do my best to live by them no matter what in the hopes that I either meet someone that is living theirs more than mine, or I inspire someone to live by theirs. Whether that be an adult or child doesn't particularly matter.
- shpxnvz 17y agoI've spent the last 15 months watching what and how my baby girl learns, and I can definitively say that she does not learn only by example, which means that some other form of guidance in necessary. It's certainly true that children mimic many things we do which become ingrained behaviors in time, but it is not the only way they learn. Case in point; my daughter has never seen a person touch a hot stove, run into a table at full speed, spit food across the room, pee on the carpet, bite someone's toe, chew a crayon, or any of a thousand other things she'll attempt to do until we teach her otherwise. Let's face it, at this stage she's a chemically fueled entropy machine. Her instinct is to try everything she can think of just to see what happens. In activities where she does behave by mimicking, for instance eating, we've adopted the behavior we'd like her to learn - we eat almost exclusively what she should, but this won't stop her from attempting innumerable dangerous or socially unacceptable behaviors before she can reason for herself, and in those case there is more needed than just leading by example. Of course, the children in this research are a little bit older, and I am very curious to see how her behavior changes in the next few years.
- frossie 17y agoUnfortunately, the primary source material is behind a paywall, so I can't reference it directly. Personally, I have a negative gut reaction to guilting kids into doing what you want. I think it is a technique that is manipulative and not in a good way. Let me use the litmus test of parenting techniques: would you let someone else use that technique on your child? I would be uncomfortable if someone guilted my child into doing something against her better instincts. I can't help noting that guilt is used here to set up a negative association with a past misdeed. It is possible to do that with a variety of other unpleasant-to-the-child techniques, such as time outs, confiscating privileges etc. Also, their longtitudinal survey went up to about 5 years of age. This is a time where kids still haven't completely internalised the reasons for good behaviour (eg. social harmony) hence the need for more Pavlovian techniques. It's not clear to me that this scales to, for example, teenagers. Finally, there could be some giant selection effect here: kids who feel guilt are probably more socially sensitive than other kids, and so are more likely to behave in a way that does not cause waves. Difficult to say without reference to the primary material. Man, journal paywalls suck.
- w1ntermute 17y agojournal paywalls suck I have never understood why research funded by taxpayers' money is not available to the general public free of charge. Does anybody know why this system still exists? Edit: is http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=2726045 http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=27... the article? It says it's a "draft" (lacks the publisher's final edits) version, but it should provide you with the information you need. Edit 2: PDF: http://omploader.org/vMjd0OQ/nihms129980.pdf http://omploader.org/vMjd0OQ/nihms129980.pdf
- frossie 17y agoHuge thanks for digging that up. Not surprisingly, it doesn't say what one might think after reading the OP, with its mention of Catholic guilt. First, the term guilt is used here to describe any kind of emotional discomfort (eg. anxiety) that is associated with transgressions. Secondly, the authors accept that effortful control (elsewhere called self-regulation - what you or I might think of as internalising the rules) has a large positive effect on children's behaviour. What they set out to do is to see how they play out in different children. I am now going to grossly paraphrase the rest because I doubt anybody is still reading this: If the kid is a nervous wreck, it doesn't matter how self-regulated they are because they are going to behave anyway. If the kid is tough as nails, you had better hope they have internalised the rules or else you have a troublemaker on your hands.