4 ms·
The OpenSSL developers intentionally breaking malloc/free and making other ridiculous engineering decisions is not 'mix of coding styles', it's literally incomp
by kevingadd 12y ago
The OpenSSL developers intentionally breaking malloc/free and making other ridiculous engineering decisions is not 'mix of coding styles', it's literally incompetence.
- Alupis 12y agoI would be careful before you throw the "incompetence" word around. Remember this library was written by some of the best cryptographers around, and has been the standard for a very long time -- because, generally, it does it's job very well. If you actually look into these "ridiculous engineering decisions" you will find very good reasons why they did things the way they did. With that said, of course it may be able to be done better. All code can be done better. Remember the OpenSSL team was severely underfunded, and severely understaffed. So it's not fair to label them as "incompetent" one bit. It's very easy to be an armchair quarterback.
- octo_t 12y agoI think the key term in your comment is "cryptographer". Not software engineer, but cryptographer. The actual encryption that goes on in openssl is very good, but the engineering which surrounds that cryptography - not so much.
- mentat 12y agoI think given the various side channel attacks, the actually encryption being very good might be overstating it.