4 ms·
I don't have a vested interest either; I don't work in the industry myself. What I have is a bit of a view into just how far down the road we are on the enginee
by jerf 12y ago
I don't have a vested interest either; I don't work in the industry myself. What I have is a bit of a view into just how far down the road we are on the engineering tradeoffs already.
Small and light cars aren't a miracle cure anyhow. It's amazing how small the gains are from shrinking a car. Yes, there are gains, but we're not talking taking a 40mpg sedan (in routine manufacturing now, BTW) and turning it into an 80mpg sedan "just by shrinking it a bit". You might get it down to 50mpg, but, per other articles observing that "mpg" is the wrong way to view it and "gallons per mile" starts making more sense, a 40 to 50 mpg gain is not actually that large.
No, the environment can't be saved just by "making cars smaller". You don't win anywhere near as much as you think, because of the way drag works (it's nonlinear in speed). And you can't just start taking panels off and stripping out airbags.
From what I gather, having trimmed just about everything they can from the spare tire, they're on the verge of dropping it off entirely. That's the level of optimization we're down to. There isn't much left after that. The seats are what they are due to safety regulations. The airbags are there because of safety regulations. The bumpers are there due to safety regulations. The body panels are what they are due to safety regulations and the need to survive a certain number of years out in the elements. There's just not much freedom in car design anymore.
My family doesn't include designers in them, but they relayed the designer's complaints to me that the constraints are becoming so strong that it's becoming very difficult to differentiate between cars anymore. If it feels like they all look the same lately, excepting perhaps the exact location or shape of the lights, it's because they do look the same; the combination of safety and efficiency regulations is rapidly converging down to one solution for a given form factor. Again... this is the sign of an optimization process reaching its Pareto frontier, and that you can't get big gains anymore without big sacrifices somewhere else.
You can look out in the world and see that last bit of evidence yourself, without anyone in the automotive industry. It's the same systems optimization problem faced by any engineer, even programmers.