6 ms·
"That is, what if everyone were allowed to go down to the car dealership whenever they wanted and pick out any new model, free of charge and drive it home?" "A
by jerf 12y ago
"That is, what if everyone were allowed to go down to the car dealership whenever they wanted and pick out any new model, free of charge and drive it home?"
"At this, Levitt and Dubner expected the prime minister to "light up" and say: "I see your point about the free healthcare we are doling out!" They expected him to embrace their behaviouralist argument that no one places a value on anything unless they are charged for it. In fact Cameron said nothing at all, but "the smile left his eyes", there was a quick handshake and he "hurried off to find a less ridiculous set of people with whom to meet"."
Sigh. Let me unpack this for you. The light left his eyes and he hurried off not because he was freaked out by your argument, per se, but because he realized that you didn't realize that you were an election prop, and that you were supposed to smile, say what helped him get elected by giving him the veneer of Scientific Authority (TM), then bask in the afterglow and get some money thrown your way for some research or something, and probably get to write some public report that he would promise to read and make some noise about. You'd have been given a gravy train ticket for the duration of this deal. Also you'd be expected to explain to the press why his pet theory or proposal was fully rational and explained by your economics, and why by implication everyone who is against it are dumb and maybe a little evil people standing in the way of Science and Progress for the UK. Regardless of whether any of that was true.
Instead, you showed that you were naive enough to believe that he had any actual interest in his options being constrained by science or rationality, that you were actually taken in by his transparent rhetoric, and lo, you were discarded as soon as was convenient. He probably also significantly lowered his intelligence estimate of you.
This is not cynicism. This is politics. It's just how it works, and anyone who would care to challenge me with this theory being cynical and incorrect (and don't forget the "incorrect" part), I invite you to come up with an alternate theory as to why they were shuffled off stage so quickly, if Cameron's initial enthusiasm for science was genuine.
And, no sarcasm, plaudits for refusing to follow along and be corrupted. I hope this article is itself a bit of a fashionable pose about how as an incorruptible scientist the thought of taking a dirty ticket to the gravy train simply never crossed your mind, though, because the alternative would be... unflattering.
- adwf 12y agoYeah they definitely made a mistake going after the NHS first. Even if it might have been a good idea, it's completely politically untenable. A UK politician saying that the NHS sucks and we should privatise/pay for it, would be a bit like a US politician declaring he's an Atheist - political suicide.
- manicdee 12y agoHow is privatising health care a good idea?
- adwf 12y agoIt isn't in my opinion, but I'd at least accept the possibility in the scientific sense. However, given that the US is the only major developed nation without some form of socialised healthcare - and they pay double what we do per capita and still can't provide healthcare for all - I'd imagine that socialised would prove to be the best in any experiment.
- Ntrails 12y agoActually, they apparently didn't even consider whether an argument in applicable. The whole point of the gatekeeper and waiting list systems is to ration healthcare. People can only get a free car if the salesman can see they have a valid need. And they have to arrange an appointment to see said salesman. This is not a story of incorruptible science, perfectly applied. It's a story of naively applying a one fits all model and being confused when people think you're an idiot.
- adwf 12y agoI agree, they seem to be trying to compare unlimited healthcare to unlimited travel. I don't know about them, but I don't tend to go into hospital and ask "Can I have 3 broken leg repairs and some chemotherapy please", "But you only have two legs and no cancer", "but it's free!". It just doesn't happen like that, they've applied the wrong model. I'm not surprised that if that's the argument they presented to Cameron, he showed them the door. He may not be my cup of tea, but he's not an idiot.
- pjc50 12y agoAnyone expecting UK politics to suddenly get all evidence-based was failing to pay attention to what happened to David Nutt and the Advisory Council on Misuse of Drugs when they suggested an end to the war on drugs and got condemned for it. (What the government wanted from "nudge" was a way of persuading people to do things, such as lose weight, behave, and pay taxes, without being explicit about it and encountering resistance. This led to the "nudge unit": http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-26030205 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-26030205 which has itself now been privatised.)
- manicdee 12y agoCan you expand on the idea that providing free transport to a city of people necessarily involves handing out free cars?