>> "Besides this, it is not at all clear that private sharing of digital information is automatically detrimental to musicians." Seems like this would be prett

>> "Besides this, it is not at all clear that private sharing of digital information is automatically detrimental to musicians." Seems like this would be pretty easy to work out. Look at the amount of money musicians made 30 years ago and compare it with today. >> "Whereas it used to be the case that you needed a record deal signed with a major label to have anyone even hear your music, these days you can become a major star, making a comfortable living off your music without ever signing a contract with a major label." This needs to be proven. Show me some of these big stars. If I look through the top 100 albums or singles I doubt I'll find 5 that have done it without the help of a label.