2 ms·
> You seem to be claiming that the laws against meth ruin more lives than meth addiction itself? Actually, I'm claiming that the laws against meth do not reduc
by anamax 17y ago
> You seem to be claiming that the laws against meth ruin more lives than meth addiction itself?
Actually, I'm claiming that the laws against meth do not reduce any of the problems with meth addiction. In short, they provide no benefits. However, they do have costs.
The value of a program is the difference between the realized benefits and the incurred costs. The war on drugs doesn't have significant realized benefits. (I don't place much value on the "we're saying that drugs are wrong" benefit.)
> The data we have say differently.
Oh really? What data shows that the laws against meth reduce the costs of meth use? How about the amount of meth use? How about the availability of meth? (Seizures don't necessarily cause scarcity. Jailing 100k meth suppliers doesn't matter if we still have "enough" meth suppliers to satisfy demand.)
If something isn't doing anything about the problem, it isn't a solution, it's merely another problem.
- tsally 17y agoI never claimed that the current war on drugs is effective, only that meth should be illegal. A more effective methodology for shutting down meth production is fine by me.
- anamax 17y ago> I never claimed that the current war on drugs is effective, only that meth should be illegal. Why should meth be illegal if making it illegal isn't effective. We're spending a lot of resources on the war on drugs. If the benefit that we're getting isn'g greater than the costs that we're incurring, why are we spending those costs? > A more effective methodology for shutting down meth production is fine by me. That's nice, but what do we do until then? I'm all for trying experiments, but when something fails, it's important to take it down, if for no other reason than its continued existence/drain/waste demonstrates that the "we'll try this and if it doesn't work" argument is a lie.