7 ms·
> Your line of reasoning is an instance of a common strain of intellectual laziness: "I don't agree with you, therefore your motives and intentions must be bad
by wtallis 12y ago
> Your line of reasoning is an instance of a common strain of intellectual laziness: "I don't agree with you, therefore your motives and intentions must be bad or self-serving."
That's not really intellectual laziness. If two people disagree on an issue that's not purely subjective, then the disagreement must ultimately stem from at least one of three things: (1) the parties are working from different facts; (2) the parties are working toward different goals with different motives and intentions; (3) at least one of the parties' reasoning is flawed. When appellate judges so clearly spend a lot of time gathering information and thinking through their reasoning, it makes (2) seem relatively more likely.