5 ms·
> get a lawyer Because this is the world we should want to live in? Where you must pay a member of the protection racket to mediate publishing knowledge of som
by mindslight 12y ago
> get a lawyer
Because this is the world we should want to live in? Where you must pay a member of the protection racket to mediate publishing knowledge of someone else's extreme wrongdoing?
That is terrible advice. Its road ends with TORified disclosures of weaponized automated exploits, because as pure info sec has shown, that's the only way the message ever gets across when you give people the insulation to not listen.
Publicly demonstrating these exploits to an amicable media is the best idea I've heard yet, as they have straightforward real-world effects that can be easily illustrated. If certain manufacturers choose to send goons after you rather than fix their buggy products, then the community-accepted custom for them can change to psuedonymous press releases accompanied by a video with a (mock) live human subject.
- ijk 12y ago> Because this is the world we should want to live in? Where you must pay a member of the protection racket to mediate publishing knowledge of someone else's extreme wrongdoing? Might be useful to distinguish between the ideal and the actual: in an ideal world, you of course shouldn't need a lawyer and the manufacturers should smilingly thank anyone who discovers an exploit and tells them. In this less-than-perfect world I'd suggest getting a lawyer and then going to the media.
- sliverstorm 12y agoMaybe if we just wish harder...
- tripzilch 12y agoInteresting how digital rights, when they apply to privacy and outrage about eavesdropping it's "just the USA", but when they refer to liability in an out-of-control justice system it's as if does work the same way in the entire world.
- thenmar 12y agoCan you elaborate on how lawyers are "member[s] of the protection racket"?
- hangonhn 12y agoI was about to ask something similar. Ever wonder how other people view us engineers or white hat hackers? Misunderstood by outsiders? Perhaps this is applicable to the legal profession as well.
- sliverstorm 12y agoIt's right there on the form they sign in blood at their initiation ritual. I forget whether they use their own blood, or the blood of the sacrificial goat though.
- mindslight 12y agoThe oft-recommended prudence of having a lawyer's advice for most any action in the public realm indicates a de facto protection racket. Specifically, the above comment references having a lawyer handle (and moderate) what should be open technical communication with the manufacturer and regulatory agencies, the implication being that simply disclosing facts put you at grave risk from an endlessly complex legal system.
- thomasz 12y ago1) You really shouldn't have an open conversation about knowledge that can easily kill people. 2) I'm pretty sure that communication isn't the problem, the problem is that he want's to pressure them into fixing their mess, and that is exactly the point where things get messy from a legal perspective. I can hardly imagine a legal system in which a situation like this would be unproblematic.
- baddox 12y ago> 1) You really shouldn't have an open conversation about knowledge that can easily kill people. You mean like guns, toxins, and martial arts?
- ebrenes 12y agoDon't forget vehicles, diseases, sudden deceleration, falls, drops and darwin award winning behaviour. It's important that people be aware of the risks they face, and seeking to silence that conversation is not helpful. If anything, it will create an environment where any perpetators might go unpunished because it's just implausible they did what they did.
- brianpgordon 12y agoPeople say that because a lawyer can really, really help you in your cause. The law is byzantine and someone who can navigate it and act as an advisor could make a big difference.
- Qualman 12y agoClaiming a medical company's life-saving device will kill your family on national news will almost without a doubt land you on the receiving end of a libel lawsuit, warranted or not. Not having to use lawyers would be nice, but it's not happening in this paradigm. This is a naïve response.
- aroch 12y agoThat's what anti-SLAPP laws are for.