4 ms·
It's not quite "this could kill people" but rather "this could be used to kill someone." But there are a lot of things that one person could use against another
by zaroth 12y ago
It's not quite "this could kill people" but rather "this could be used to kill someone." But there are a lot of things that one person could use against another person to kill them, ethically, what does adding this thing to the list change?
If you discovered / disclosed a particular way the unit could malfunction and kill someone it seems like that's put in a different class; in that case you're a hero saving lives. But if you report on a technique someone could use to cause the device to malfunction, it's treated completely differently.
I think a related and important message is that pacemaker "malfunctions" should be treated as possibly suspicious.
- Kliment 12y agoThis is a way to kill someone at a distance, with no obvious trace leading to you, and using nothing but an off the shelf laptop or phone. It's significantly more dangerous than any of the other known methods of murder because of the reduced risk to the murderer.
- zaroth 12y agoMy understanding is that pacemakers, insulin pumps, and such have only limited short-range wireless capability. It's not exactly a 3G connection with a public facing IP address. As long as you still need proximity and individual targeting, I think it's not a paradigm shift in murder.
- noir_lord 12y agoThe short range is to do with the antenna in the device which is (obviously) limited to a certain size. A larger aerial on the attacking device will allow for communication over a greater range. The paradigm shift is when you can sit 6 rows back at a baseball stadium and take out someone or walk through their subway car and kill them. There is no trace evidence and done in a crowd at rush hour essentially no chance of getting caught, heart attacks happen all the damn time.