2 ms·
The author is not teaching degrees, she's teaching a high school class. There's a clarification at the top of the article (in italics, directly after the headin
by vacri 12y ago
The author is not teaching degrees, she's teaching a high school class. There's a clarification at the top of the article (in italics, directly after the heading), appropriate commentary peppered throughout the article body, and half a dozen comments here on HN to that effect.
I'm astounded that so many people are pinging the author for not being on the ball, yet missing all the massive signposts saying "This is a high-school environment, not university".
- benihana 12y agoI think that disclaimer was added after the fact. I don't remember it being there when I read this story the first time. Either way, I didn't see it at all when I read the article. I'm willing to admit that I'm just not on the ball, but the fact that a bunch of people missed it is rather telling, isn't it?
- vacri 12y agoIn one of the final paragraphs, she repeats 'teaching children' a couple of times, and the language in the rest of the article is high-school-related. It's not just the disclaimer. For example, how many people do post-graduate study in Education, then teach at University? Apart from the people teaching Education itself, it's a vanishingly small number. the fact that a bunch of people missed it is rather telling, isn't it Not particularly, given that the author's criticism is that folks in our industry give her short shrift and ignore what she has to say. It actually plays directly into her criticism that a bunch of us just tilted at her windmill without bothering to understand what it is that she actually does first.