3 ms·
If you're going to reduce this to a logical contradiction, then it does take away from the gender issues. I doubt Techweek will smell like roses or deserve to c
by stcredzero 12y ago
If you're going to reduce this to a logical contradiction, then it does take away from the gender issues. I doubt Techweek will smell like roses or deserve to come out Scott free. That doesn't mean we should set a pattern for knee-jerk vilification. (That ship may well have sailed and entered a canal to an entirely different ocean.)
- rhizome 12y agoIt's not a logical contradiction nor knee-jerk. They came up with a code of conduct, violated its terms themselves, and now people are reacting to that news. An unforced error on Techweek's part, and reasonable to call them out on it. The only pattern is that when you do something stupid, people call you stupid.
- stcredzero 12y agoAn unforced error on Techweek's part, and reasonable to call them out on it. The tenor and severity with which they are being called out is a bit out of whack. It's mostly out of proportion with an unintentional mistake, which probably results from emotional factors and political haymaking. It's also a mistake because of a poorly and too-generally written policy, which I am also calling out. Please re-read. That poorly and too-generally written policy is in fact my main point.
- rhizome 12y agoWell of course it was unintentional, nobody's saying it wasn't. It's just highly stupid, especially considering their history (http://chicagoinno.streetwise.co/2014/06/04/techweek-is-young-but-its-history-of-sexism-is-getting-long/ http://chicagoinno.streetwise.co/2014/06/04/techweek-is-youn...). I don't agree that the policy leaves room for misinterpretation.
- stcredzero 12y agoI never meant that it leaves room for misinterpretation. It's a bit foolishly all encompassing. It shows no awareness of the underlying issues.
- rhizome 12y agoThose underlying issues are exactly what the code of conduct was designed to prevent.
- stcredzero 12y agoNo. The code of conduct was a simplistic knee-jerk and simply bans everything sexual. Sexuality is a normal part of human existence. It's weird power dynamics in sexuality that are the problem. It was "designed" to stop sexism in the same sense that landmines are designed to prevent trespassing. All the brain dead shenanigans around this only serve to cloud and confuse people about the complex and nuanced truths. History has shown that you don't solve such problems by simply repressing everything sexual. But most people are more interested in spotlighting villains than they are in learning and solving hard problems.