3 ms·
It seems like you are mixing up revisionism with coming to a conclusion about a debatable topic. The holocaust and global warming are not differences of scale -
by mhb 17y ago
It seems like you are mixing up revisionism with coming to a conclusion about a debatable topic. The holocaust and global warming are not differences of scale - they are differences of kind.
If you question whether the holocaust occurred, you should also be questioning any other events which you didn't personally observe. And maybe even ones which did happen to you. So unless this kind of philosophical debate is what you are wrestling with, including the holocaust on your list muddies the question you are asking.
- Tichy 17y ago"you should also be questioning any other events which you didn't personally observe." Well I take it for granted that most things I see on the news are not the truth, and that I can never know the truth if I haven't been there (and even then it is debatable, as you point out). For example in wars, the official history version gets written by the winners of the wars. That is actually one reason why I avoid firm opinions about WW2 - since I witnessed the "official history fabrication" in several cases during my lifetime, why should it have been any different for WW2? I also can not personally experience the global warming or not warming. I don't see how the HC is very different from the rest of the list?
- gloob 17y agoJust for the sake of curiosity: do you believe the Roman Empire existed?
- jamesbritt 17y ago"The holocaust and global warming are not differences of scale - they are differences of kind." With global warming there are at least four positions argued: GW is real and man-made, and we need to take direct action against it; GW is bogus; GW is real and man-made, but a cost/benefit analysis for allocation of limited resources says we should still spend time and money on other things (fighting malaria, improving education) besides carbon reduction; GW is real but natural, so attempts to change it via human behavior are a waste. The mainstream media (and many online writers) like to portray controversy (real or invented) as having only two sides: Politics is always left v right, Democrat v Republican (there's no in-between or off-the-2d-axis thinking); health care reform debate is only for or against the Obama plan (you can't possibly be for reform yet think Obama's plan is wrong); global warming is either a man-made issue that demands immediate direct efforts or else it's total nonsense (one cannot possibly agree with the science but disagree about what's the best use of time and money). There are two issues here. One is how to deal with out-and-out revisionists. The other is how to encourage healthy debate on complex nuanced topics, part of which is to not demonize as revisionists or deniers or obstructionists all dissenters from the orthodox view.