5 ms·
She wasn't "grappling", she was retelling what was probably the most emotionally trying experience of her entire life. Cut her some slack maybe?
by peterwwillis 12y ago
She wasn't "grappling", she was retelling what was probably the most emotionally trying experience of her entire life. Cut her some slack maybe?
- tptacek 12y agoShe wrote an article that is in large part a defense of leaving toddlers alone in parked cars. That was her choice. It is reasonable to criticize an article on its own terms.
- peterwwillis 12y agoYou called her an asshole. That isn't criticizing an article. You interpret it as a defense of leaving toddlers alone, but really it's just a story. There's a lot of important points to it, like the fucked up judicial and legislative process, and the fact that all parents make mistakes. It's not a whitewash. It's real life.
- tptacek 12y agoI called her an asshole for summing up the risks to a toddler left alone in a parked car as: "He wasn’t kidnapped or assaulted or forgotten or dragged across state lines by a carjacker." That's really how she summed the risks up! It's an excerpt of a paragraph, not the whole paragraph, but it's the only part of the paragraph that acknowledges risk. And those aren't the real risks. The real risks are (a) that you've underestimated how likely it is that the heat in the car will injure your child (she touches on this later and it wasn't a factor here) and (b) that your child will escape your parked car and wander around, practically invisible, in a parking lot full of moving vehicles. The whole article is full of misdirection like this; appeals to "helicopter parenting", or whole grafs about how enraged she was that another person called the police upon finding her child alone in a parked car. It's simply a terrible article. It's meant to stir up outrage at the nanny-state and busybody bystanders and mythologized risks to children, but it repeatedly, reliably misses every mark it tries to hit. In that regard, it's at least valuable as a rorschach test to how carefully people think about what they read.
- imgabe 12y agoI don't find that it advocates leaving toddlers alone in parked cars at all. She states in multiple places that it was a bad decision. What it does advocate is that this shouldn't require legal action. The response in terms of police manpower and court time is wildly out of proportion to the risk.
- tptacek 12y agoSkip forward to the part where she's conversing with her attorney. The attorney sums the situation up as a lapse in judgement. She responds with anger towards the bystander who called her child --- alone in a car --- in to the police. Or reread the section where she interviews Skenazy. The Skenazy section overtly argues that leaving kids alone in parked cars is a negligible risk. No, think you're wrong. I think this is a piece that says, in effect, that people should chill the hell out about leaving four year olds alone in parked cars.
- imgabe 12y agoIn all the articles you linked above, not one involved a child being left alone in a car and escaping, then getting hit in the parking lot. So, yes, until there's a documented case of that actually happening I would consider the risk to be negligible. However, if you arrest the parent, saddle them with months of legal fees, potentially take their child away and put them into a foster care system, that's not without risks to the child as well. It's not like having your parents impoverished and potentially put in jail does wonders for a child's future either. That has a far higher probability of happening than your so far completely hypothetical scenario of the child escaping from the car in five minutes and wandering around the parking lot until getting hit.
- tptacek 12y agoThat's because parents don't generally leave four year olds alone in cars, not because four year olds left alone in cars generally do just fine.
- greedo 12y agoWords matter. A four year old, unless developmentally disabled, is not a toddler... A toddler implies someone who "toddles" as if at a very early age, and leads readers to infer that the child was closer to 2 than four. (Unless my daughter was precocious when she was walking at 11 months.)