3 ms·
I think it was Scientific American or another such magazine that ran a story, [...] real theoretical and computational neuroscientists [...] admit things
by michaelt 12y ago
I think it was Scientific American or another such
magazine that ran a story, [...] real theoretical and
computational neuroscientists [...] admit things they
would never say in a grant application, they are
definitely trying to achieve whole-brain emulation.
Another possibility is they're actually working on the things their grant applications say, but when pushed and offered drinks by journalists looking for a story, they'll extrapolate their research far enough to reach something cool-sounding.
For example, if I'm researching image correlation techniques, which have applications in machine vision, which has applications in obstacle detection and tracking, which has applications in self driving cars, I could tell a journalist that I'm working on image processing techniques with potential applications in self driving cars.
Is that me admitting things I would never say in a grant application, that I'm trying to achieve self-driving cars? Or am I working on exactly what my grant application says, but I've simplified it and added context because I know Scientific American isn't going to be publishing articles about efficient convolving and fast fourier transforms any time soon?
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoFrankly, I think the real answer is "both", but that might just be my optimism about the... let's call it soulfulness of most scientists. To me it seems as though one would be nuts to keep up in academic science just for the sake of the boring, tiny, insignificant bullcrap one writes in grant applications to sound impressive; to me it seems as if a scientist must have some actual dream burning in him that keeps him going. On the other hand, my real-world observations say that for many scientists, the burning dream heating their blood and getting them up in the morning to deal with all the bullshit is... careerist ego-stroking. So on further reflection, ugh.