2 ms·
You know, if we had DRM infrastructure we could actually trust, this wouldn't be a problem. Granted, having DRM we can trust may well be itself an insurmountabl
by stcredzero 12y ago
You know, if we had DRM infrastructure we could actually trust, this wouldn't be a problem. Granted, having DRM we can trust may well be itself an insurmountable problem.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoYour comment doesn't parse due to an ambiguity. Who is we? If "we" are supposed to be all of us as owners of computing devices, I'm not sure how DRM is supposed to help. Maybe the ambiguity is in what you think DRM is. If "we" is "they" as the overlords who manufacture our stuff, having a DRM infrastructure they can trust would be a primary source of the problem, because it would consequently be one that we can't.
- stcredzero 12y agoIf "we" are supposed to be all of us as owners of computing devices, I'm not sure how DRM is supposed to help. Maybe the ambiguity is in what you think DRM is. This is exactly the knee-jerk populist fluff we need people to actually think through. If we was everyone, then we could have agents that use our private key to sign and encrypt things on our behalf, but be a bit more confident that it wouldn't fall into the wrong hands. (Actually, we'd best spawn agents with a time-limited signed ephemeral private key.) "We as in the overlords" is so predominant as a model, people have forgotten to think about the implications of such tools for themselves. Most DRM "discussion" gets reduced to "two legs baaad, four legs goood."
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> If we was everyone, then we could have agents that use our private key to sign and encrypt things on our behalf, but be a bit more confident that it wouldn't fall into the wrong hands. (Actually, we'd best spawn agents with a time-limited signed ephemeral private key.) What are we supposed to gain from "agents" here? You have your private key, nobody else has it, you sign things with it. If somebody else has it then it isn't your private key. For DRM to even pretend to work for any purpose that anyone thinks of when people say "DRM" (i.e. preventing the copying of bits given to untrusted parties), it has to be a centralized trust model. Some party that "everyone" can trust has to certify that the device or software you're giving the secret bits to is not going to divulge them. The problem is that there is nobody that everybody can trust. Trust is not a global hierarchy, it's a relativistic relationship between peers. If (as it seems) you're trying to achieve something separate that may work using a distributed trust model, why are you calling it DRM?
- stcredzero 12y agoIf somebody else has it then it isn't your... ...data. This is how things work right now. For DRM to even pretend to work for any purpose that anyone thinks of when people say "DRM" (i.e. preventing the copying of bits given to untrusted parties), it has to be a centralized trust model. That is what we have now. If (as it seems) you're trying to achieve something separate that may work using a distributed trust model, why are you calling it DRM? How is the acronym "Digital Rights Management" inappropriate for this, without bringing up fluffy sentiment? Actually, I would prefer "Trusted Execution."
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoI don't see how "this is what we have now" is a refutation of anything. The status quo is not optimal. > How is the acronym "Digital Rights Management" inappropriate for this, without bringing up fluffy sentiment? That's like asking why the acronym "Structured Query Language" is inappropriate for a new language for making queries to search engines. The problem is that it already means something else.
- stcredzero 12y agoI don't see how "this is what we have now" is a refutation of anything. The status quo is not optimal. My point exactly, and it doesn't have to be that way. Also, why does it have to be a refutation? I've met a few great minds in my time. They are the ones who create a small cloud or tree of meanings from what they hear or read, and try to make them all work out of curiosity. The problem is that it already means something else. "Means" in the sense that people feel a certain way about it, or means in the sense of the definitions of the words? That's exactly what I mean in terms of fluffy sentiment. Back to great minds. Great minds try to refute things by trying as hard as they can to make them work, even challenging their own assumptions to do so. Also, aren't you a member of TX/RX?
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> My point exactly, and it doesn't have to be that way. OK, that still doesn't mean it's a good idea to say that some useful new combination of PGP, TLS and AES-NI is "DRM." > That's exactly what I mean in terms of fluffy sentiment. It's not "fluffy sentiment" to believe that words mean what other people understand them to mean. If you want to start a new nation-wide left-leaning political party, calling it the National Socialist Party is a Bad Idea, regardless of whether it satisfies each of the characteristics of being national, socialist, and a political party. > Also, aren't you a member of TX/RX? Why, is there someone there impersonating me?
- Zigurd 12y agoThe problem is that what content publishers think of as "DRM" is something THEY can trust, which means YOU can't. You might have something in mind that indivudal users can trust, but that is something other than DRM by a content publishers definition.