3 ms·
Only so much room on the planet? I take it you haven't ever experienced the population densities of either NYC or HK? The fact of the matter is the world can
by cwan 17y ago
Only so much room on the planet? I take it you haven't ever experienced the population densities of either NYC or HK? The fact of the matter is the world can support far more people than there are today. Further, world population will peak and some say it will do so by 2070 though I personally suspect it will be sooner given how economies are able to leapfrog with better technologies (http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn1108-global-population-to-peak-in-2070.html http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn1108-global-population...). I think you've made a number of assumptions here based on facts that do not exist. And it is based on these assumptions that your prescription is as much unnecessary as it is dehumanizing.
Forced reductions in births is sterilization - partial or otherwise. And what's worse is that you would limit your approach to the developing world where they have the least number of options when their problem isn't social management or culture - but their oppressive governments that attempt to capture wealth for themselves and their cronies and in turn resulting in higher infant mortalities, inability to save making children effectively a form of social security.
While your proposed solution may not technically exist, it is this line of reasoning that has resulted in coerced insertions of depo provera in the developing world and again, the worst part is that it is a solution in search of a problem.
- derefr 17y agoThe world can't sustain a population coverage similar to that of NYC or HK. Those population centers are supported by millions of acres of farmland that grow the food they eat. If there are enough people, then we don't run out of living space for them... but we do run out of farmland. Secondly, population will peak because of the very factor I mentioned—people in industrial societies are too busy to have kids. However, one important fact about industrial societies is that they constantly seek to improve themselves and gain efficiency. More automation means more people out of work (or consumerism-for-the-sake-of-feeding-the-cycle, but I'm supposing we ignore that option.) Take this to its limit, and no one works (except on creative pursuits, but that won't be everyone.) What do you suppose the rest spend their time doing? I'm thinking population will start shooting straight back up in a post-industrial society. Not because each couple has more kids, but because there are more couples, well, coupling. You haven't explained to me yet what's wrong with sterilization in-and-of-itself; you're using it like Americans tend to use the word "socialist," assuming that it's scary without explaining precisely why it's scary. Couples can still have kids under this scheme. Couples can still have just as many kids. It would just take, say, ten times as long for a couple to conceive (the regular period being a month), meaning that there would be a nine-month "fallow" period between pregnancies. Each couple could have the same number of kids, but half the children would end up in the following generational cohort, meaning that the yearly growth rate would be halved. Since conception is harder, some couples would give up after a smaller number of children, lowering the total produced. This is, in the end, a much more lax scheme than even China's one-child rule. I can see where you are coming from in that developing counties need to have their oppression lifted in order to stop "investing in the future" with overproduction of children. However, consider this: if you do kill off the warlords, and ensure that all the infant mortality goes away, but leave behind a current population far exceeding their own supply of resources, what will happen to that generation, and the few proceeding from it, before they reach the point where the cultural tradition of overproducing young gives way to an industrial lifestyle? Assuming the resources go unequally distributed, won't those still in poverty try to take those resources by force, and become new warlords? War and anarchy will break out wherever population greatly exceeds resources, and there is no infrastructure (e.g. police) to hold down an oppressive government from forming. To beat tyranny, the population must sharply drop, or the resources must greatly rise, along with the removal of the government, or the attractor won't be escaped. Food genetically modified to lower fertility does both. It might not be the best solution, but it's a solution, and unlike most others, it's one that's impossible to screw up. Contraceptives can be discarded for religious or cultural reasons, but food must be eaten. Educators' teachings can be ignored as misguided, but your body's egg or sperm count is a cold, hard fact. Other resources given as aid can be confiscated by a warlord for their value (OLPC laptops, anyone?), but what value does food that lowers your virility have to a warlord that could just as well eat something else? I'm not suggesting there isn't a better, social solution. I'm just saying that as purely technical solutions go, this one is pretty damn air-tight.
- aaronsw 17y agoWhy would more automation lead to more people out of work? Automation simply increases productivity; productivity gains have increased by numerous factors of 10 in the past few centuries and workforce participation rates have consistently _increased_.
- cwan 17y ago"I'm just saying that as purely technical solutions go, this one is pretty damn air-tight." Such is the unfortunate myopia of relying on biologists for economic analyses. The solution for actual resource shortages is trade. As for the farmland issue, it's technically feasible to build a couple skyscrapers with hydroponics with a small footprint that would satisfy those requirements though we're also not running out of farmland or ability to grow food - and our ability to be increasingly productive with existing farmland increases. Consider for example China - where those like Paul Erlich had predicted massive famines. After implementing property rights, China moved from becoming a massive importer of food to being a massive exporter - ie generating large surpluses. And there remains vast tracts of potential farmland that is underused as you move inland. You assume war and anarchy break out wherever population greatly exceeds resources but this is a false assumption. People create their own resources and develop new ones which is why the long term trend for nearly all if not all commodities is negative sloping (very much counter intuitive since supply and demand should suggest that with greater numbers of people and fixed resources prices should rise - but the reality is that resources aren't fixed because of substitutes). I note further a number of Asian countries where demand greatly exceeds demand - HK and Singapore being two. HK was pretty much a barren rock before the British got there. As for the term sterilization - I don't consider it scary so much as repugnant. It's proposed for societies other than one's own or or one's own social class. It is inherently oppressive as it is using your power to enforce your own value choices. Sure, I suppose one could consider it to be a technically feasible insomuch as slaughter or genocide might be, but it is as much morally repugnant as it is unnecessary.