3 ms·
> And using third-party engines doesn't directly address a lot of the other questions about Linux gaming (drivers, fragmentation, back-catalog games), it doesn'
by ekianjo 12y ago
> And using third-party engines doesn't directly address a lot of the other questions about Linux gaming (drivers, fragmentation, back-catalog games), it doesn't help out with the large number of AAA games that are made on first-party engines (Square Enix uses a lot of Crystal Engine, Ubisoft has a handful of its own engines, EA games use their own engines for the most part), and it doesn't help turn Linux into a more compelling general-purpose desktop OS.
Wow, a lot of points made in a very few words. Here's my take on your comments:
* Drivers: massively improved for nVidia cards, probably very close to Windows performance nowadays. For ATI, I guess the state of it is "meh", but it's getting a bit better progressively. For now gaming on Linux should be with nVidia (and Intel).
* Fragmentation: this problem is a myth and has been debunked so many times already, I don't want to discuss it here.
* Back catalog games: a lot of it can be handled with WINE with no additional modification needed.
* AAA games engines: Square Enix is a Japanese publisher, focused on Consoles first, then PC, and when they mean PC they only have the image of Windows because Linux is non-existent in Japan (mostly). So I would not be surprised if they were the very last ones to jump on the bandwagon. UbiSoft has become a "console first" publisher as well, so I don't hope much from their side as well.
* compelling desktop OS: Linux in some of its best distros IS already very compelling, much more than Windows 8 where you have to relearn everything from scratch again. It's faster, you have repositories for updates, Firefox runs like a dream on it (on the same hardware I always find the Windows version running way more slowly), and you have great Free Software for most of the uses you need, without viruses, ads and stuff like that. It's VERY functional. Of course some people will bitch about not having Adobe products, or X or Y software, but you can always keep a double boot or a virtual machine if you really need something. Distros get updates automatically, instead of the ancient way of doing updates on Windows with service packs and the like. Since I've switched to Linux years ago I have never looked back, except for games and video editing. And I know I'm not the only one, and I see Linux distros improving release after release.
- cwyers 12y agoColdpie's posts in this thread seem to suggest that fragmentation is more of an issue than you want to admit here, at least. In terms of drivers... "very close" is not the same as "as good as," much less "better." Which is again the problem here -- in order to supplant a dominant market leader you actually have to do something better. If your drivers are VERY CLOSE to the quality of Windows, for a a subset of the leading manufacturers, and you can get MOST of the big AAA publishers to do ports, and a LOT of the back catalog can run under WINE... do you see what I'm saying? It's playing catch-up, and it's not quite getting to parity, and even parity is unlikely to get significant market share. As for desktop Linux -- that's a whole other kettle of fish, but I think you'll find that most of the people who are ready to switch to Linux on the desktop already have, and as you say are dual-booting for games. Unless something happens there to convince more people that Linux on the desktop is a compelling alternative, then Linux's overall desktop market penetration is probably a pretty good guide to what Linux's share of the gaming PC market could be unless Valve or somebody is able to provide a compelling "better than Windows" experience in at least ONE aspect.
- ekianjo 12y ago> Coldpie's posts in this thread seem to suggest that fragmentation is more of an issue than you want to admit here, at least. Coldpie's answers about Steam suggest he does not really know how Valve adresses these concerns, however. In a matter of days, the Steam client, originally only made to run on Ubuntu, was running on all other major distros and games ran without issues as far as I know. I don't use Ubuntu and I have had zero problem so far with running Steam Linux games. > Which is again the problem here -- in order to supplant a dominant market leader you actually have to do something better You don't have to supplant a dominant leader to exist. Macs exist just fine without being leaders on the market. Even for gaming I'd prefer run the SAME game on Linux if it were available just because my OS is faster to boot, and uses less resources than Windows and therefore my game can benefit from additional RAM and less overhead. > It's playing catch-up, and it's not quite getting to parity, and even parity is unlikely to get significant market share. It does not matter. These are additional consumers you are leaving off the table if you don't provide games for them. If your game sell millions, 1-2% is in the order of several dozens of thousands of paying customers. You may consider it to be negligible, but that's literally a couple of millions USD of revenues you don't get, and if you planned your game to be multiplatform in the first place, there's no reason not to service them. > but I think you'll find that most of the people who are ready to switch to Linux on the desktop already have, I believe Linux can grow much, much further than where it is now. Currently its awareness in the general population is close to nil. Only people like us know about Linux, and we're a super small minority. Even among gamers Linux awareness is very limited, so there's a lot that can be done in that field before saying the "Linux market is capped". > unless Valve or somebody is able to provide a compelling "better than Windows" experience in at least ONE aspect. Steam Machines will(should) be better than consoles (power wise) and Windows (direct boot into gaming system, OS stripped to the bare essential) and could drive further adoption of Linux, and there will be quite a number of games available for them when they launch. I'm hopeful. But it will take time. Windows gaming will not go away in a single day.