4 ms·
This is a horrifying suggestion. An individual donor at an aid agency meeting said something similar where a cost effective healthcare alternative was being de
by cwan 17y ago
This is a horrifying suggestion. An individual donor at an aid agency meeting said something similar where a cost effective healthcare alternative was being developed in sub-Saharan Africa. His question was "what if you're successful? won't having more people damage the environment?"
The rest of us in the room were stunned - this man explicitly valued the environment over human life. You make a similar mistake in attempting to smite a symptom. Poverty is never caused by the lack of resources - or the related overblown fears of overpopulation (look up why oil is often called the Devil's excrement where it's discovered particularly in the developing world). It's bad governments - prior and/or current. High birth rates drop dramatically after a society industrializes.
What makes the suggestion repulsive (as much as it is unequivocally absurd) is that instead trying to alleviate suffering and addressing the root causes of absolute poverty, you're effectively starving and forcing deeply impoverished people who are in no position to deny food to accept sterilization.
If you're reading HN, you've already hit a genetic jackpot having the opportunities that most of the world will never have. Not only would this be a slippery slope (if you accept forced sterilizations for the "greater good", why not deny needed medical drugs and treatments or worse?), it's an unnecessary slope. So instead of trying to provide the poor with economic opportunities you'd provide them with sterility?
- bokonist 17y agoIt's bad governments - prior and/or current. I agree with this. But what should the developed countries do about fixing African governments? Anything? To go off the anti-PC deep end in another direction I pose a different solution. The past fifty years of African history has been an unmitigated disaster. The entire continent has been plagued by war, famine, disease, awful governments, and economic stagnation or decline. The years before that - the colonial years - were generally peaceful and saw rising economic prosperity. We have model B which is awful. We have model A which worked reasonably well. The answer to me seems blindingly obvious: figure out a way to bring back colonialism.
- cwan 17y agoThe solution is multi fold. Solutions include immediately offering trade free of tariffs, to help countries stabilize following the collapse of their governments (there are a few good presentations on TED.com about this), and offer the expertise to create legal structures that enshrine property rights for all. We don't need nor would we want colonialism (or even the mercantilist approach France still practices to a certain degree). We can however provide good examples and support countries that attempt to make the transition. We can help make it as smooth and painfree as possible and ensure that the incentives exist to do so.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoI propose spending $2 billion/5 years to encourage better government. At the end of a 5 year period, we use some objective criteria to determine the best and worst African leader. The best gets a prize of $1 billion for his own personal enjoyment. The worst gets a prize of $1 billion for the personal enjoyment of whoever brings us his head.
- derefr 17y agoIn case you can't tell, I never said anyone should be sterilized. Lowered fertility and infertility are different things; basically, if you have to try N times as hard to successfully procreate, it will take you f(N) as long, and so you will, in all likelihood, have 1/f(N) as many kids. This is not the same as not being able to procreate at all, which, applied to the entire population, means effectively committing genocide. All lowering the fertility of developing cultures would do is concentrate each family's wealth (fewer children to feed means each gets a better chance), thereby creating more opportunities for highly-educated individuals to create this "good government" that is necessary to effect industrialization. But frankly, I wasn't really talking about poverty. Overpopulation is a problem we will eventually face as a species, whether or not any one of us lives in poverty. There's only so much room on this planet, and [eventually] living on other worlds just isn't looking very promising as an alternative. "Social solutions" aren't; they're really social management of the problem by given cultures, and cultures eventually fall. As I was saying, one of the main "problems" we have as humans is that we're just too good at breeding. When left to our own devices, without cultural mores in one specific direction or the other, we naturally produce too many more humans. When we figure out genetic engineering, and how to create safe, stable methods of delivering genetic sequence "alterations" to the entire species (retroviruses that won't mutate, etc.) one of the first things we should do is lower our own natural fertility rate. More sex, less babies, fewer complications all-around. (Also note that industrial cultures have below-2.0 reproductive rates, but that says nothing about their fertility, just their willingness to put their work before the goal of creating a family. A post-industrial society doesn't necessarily have work that is all-consuming enough to let you be diverted from creating a family.) But again, as should be obvious from even the nature of my suggestion (involving technologies which do not yet exist) this isn't a solution to a problem we have today. It's a solution to a problem we'll have when we're completely different people with completely different cultural mores, who probably would think this is either wrongheaded in the archaic sense ("we have much more civilized solutions, involving technologies they could never imagine,") or too obvious to mention.
- cwan 17y agoOnly so much room on the planet? I take it you haven't ever experienced the population densities of either NYC or HK? The fact of the matter is the world can support far more people than there are today. Further, world population will peak and some say it will do so by 2070 though I personally suspect it will be sooner given how economies are able to leapfrog with better technologies (http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn1108-global-population-to-peak-in-2070.html http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn1108-global-population...). I think you've made a number of assumptions here based on facts that do not exist. And it is based on these assumptions that your prescription is as much unnecessary as it is dehumanizing. Forced reductions in births is sterilization - partial or otherwise. And what's worse is that you would limit your approach to the developing world where they have the least number of options when their problem isn't social management or culture - but their oppressive governments that attempt to capture wealth for themselves and their cronies and in turn resulting in higher infant mortalities, inability to save making children effectively a form of social security. While your proposed solution may not technically exist, it is this line of reasoning that has resulted in coerced insertions of depo provera in the developing world and again, the worst part is that it is a solution in search of a problem.