3 ms·
"Theory: there isn't anything really all that wrong with most people; it's all in their minds, so the placebo works." Nope. Placebos can really and truly cure
by ars 17y ago
"Theory: there isn't anything really all that wrong with most people; it's all in their minds, so the placebo works."
Nope. Placebos can really and truly cure things. And not just things that are in the mind.
For example the immune system is under brain control, and placebos can affect it. Allergies can be cured by placebo, ref: http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=27460 http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=27...
Lots of things that you would not expect can be cured by placebo.
Read some drug trials (or those inserts in drug packages) and notice how in pretty much all cases the placebo group improved relative to the starting point.
As I said in a different comment in this thread: most people refuse to believe placebos can work, and say things like what you did "it's all in their head", "there was nothing actually wrong with them". But they really do work.
- indiejade 17y agoFor example the immune system is under brain control, and placebos can affect it. Then it would be the act of taking the placebo that cures, not the actual placebo itself. My theory was simply that by taking something with the expectation of a cure, many people can already be on their way to wellness because, as you mentioned, a lot of healing begins within the brain.
- adrianbg 17y agoEspecially in the case of pain this makes total sense to me. Pain is just a signal that something is wrong with you. If you believe in some deep way that the problem has been fixed, then there's no reason for your body to keep making you feel pain.