4 ms·
Crucial's MX100 solid-state drive reviewed
- tdicola 12y agoWow, nice looking drive for not a lot of money. I've been living with a 128GB SSD but find it's just a little too small. After 9-12 months or so I generally need to flatten and reinstall because a lot of junk has accumulated and I'm running out of space. A 256GB drive should be perfect, and at $100 I'm not going to agonize over the cost.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ajtaylor 12y agoI've been thinking long and hard about upgrading my Macbook Pro with a hard drive to an SSD. Which this kind of performance and value, it's looking to be a no brainer. The main thing holding me back was going from 500 GB HD => 256 GB SSD (based on price). With the MX100, I can have it all!
- stcredzero 12y agoMake sure you have Trim Enabler and a good backup system! With an SSD, performance goes up and reliability will go down. SSD manufacturers have been improving firmware in order to be able to sell ever crappier MLC memory. You will need Trim Enabler in order to preserve the performance gain. This also means that you have to restart once again whenever your software updates require a restart, in order to restore TRIM.
- osivertsson 12y agoYes a good reliable backup system is a must. I've been running SSD's since 2010 and have seen three failures from three different vendors and different drive generations. Failures range from SSD no longer being able to communicate properly over SATA, to losing chunks of data at random points in time, and freezes.
- wtallis 12y agoEssentially none of the unreliability of consumer SSDs is directly attributable to MLC flash cells wearing out. They're large enough, have enough spare area, and the wear leveling works. When a consumer SATA SSD fails, it's almost always a catastrophic failure of the controller or its firmware, and the rest of the failures are from things like losing an entire NAND package or some other critical component on the PCB. Now, it can be said that the need for good wear leveling and latency hiding is what causes the controllers and their firmware to be so complex and thus failure-prone. But the myth of SSDs wearing out needs to die. When an SSD does wear out its write endurance, it's a gradual process with lots of SMART warnings and a gradual decline in performance when the controller no longer has enough less slack space to work with, and some sporadic data corruption. It also doesn't start happening until the drive has been subjected to a lot of heavy writing - it takes months of 24/7 torture testing: http://techreport.com/review/26058/the-ssd-endurance-experiment-data-retention-after-600tb http://techreport.com/review/26058/the-ssd-endurance-experim...
- stcredzero 12y agoI had a Crucial drive fail on me during a reinstall at about a year and a half. Spolsky has also written about the reduced reliability of SSDs. It doesn't matter if it's a secondary cause of more complicated firmware from using less stable MLCs -- a crashed drive is a crashed drive. It wouldn't happen so often with SLC flash drives or Spinning platters. And yes, I took steps to reduce wear on my SSD, including installing a secondary drive, noatime, disabling local TimeMachine, and using external drives for torrenting. My SSD still died.
- dougabug 12y agoDrive reliability is far more important to me than minor differences in performance. Unfortunately, reliable information about reliability is typically absent from most sad reviews, making them not terribly useful for purchasing decisions.
- baq 12y agoit might seem redundant, but i'll reiterate: keep backups of important stuff. i personally use a spinning USB drive and it's saved my back a couple of times since i switched to ssd's.
- ggreer 12y agoSolid state drives are the most cost-effective laptop upgrade. I cannot recommend them enough. SSDs beat laptop hard disks by an order of magnitude in sequential read/write and two orders of magnitude in random access. I made the switch back in 2009, when the 80GB Intel X-25M was around $350. Since then, any computer with a hard drive has felt broken to me. If anyone reading this uses a laptop for development and it has a hard disk, please upgrade. The cost in time and frustration makes it worthwhile purely for economic reasons.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- keehun 12y agohttp://www.anandtech.com/show/8066/crucial-mx100-256gb-512gb-review http://www.anandtech.com/show/8066/crucial-mx100-256gb-512gb...
- Turing_Machine 12y agoAmazon has the 128 GB marked down to US$79.99. US$224.99 for the 512.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- zura 12y agoBtw, do SSDs make any significant difference for desktops nowadays? I mean, I power up my PC once in a day. Also, as I'm aware it doesn't really help much with compilation performance. I'm asking this from dev-centric PoV.
- buro9 12y agoYes. Even if you still need large storage capacity having the primary drive be an SSD will yield noticeable improvements.
- MaulingMonkey 12y ago> Btw, do SSDs make any significant difference for desktops nowadays? I mean, I power up my PC once in a day. Depends on your workload. Mine now frequently involves accessing far more data than will fit into RAM, and thus will fit into the filesystem cache. There are only two options: This either flushes useful data out of the cache, or fails to enter cache in the first place. Either way, I'm going to be hitting either slow to seek spinning platters, or a fast random access SSD, even with a perfect oracle for an OS caching algorithm. Sadly, current OSes seem to be lacking even that. > Also, as I'm aware it doesn't really help much with compilation performance. Friends have seen compilation times approximately halve, even without a RAM busting workset (yes, they timed it.) I've personally seen similarly extreme performance gains in compilation, again even without a RAM busting workset. I've seen even better gains for those worksets that do bust RAM, especially if extremely IO bound. YMMV, but I do not buy or build computers unless I can put a sufficiently large SSD into it anymore. I define "sufficiently large" to include my OS, my tools (IDEs, SDKs, etc.), and a couple of active projects to fit onto. Everything stays snappy. I bought an 80GB back when they were $500, about twice the cost of any other component in any of my computers then or since (ignoring more SSDs), and still consider it money well spent. I recently bought a laptop - priorities, in order, were: Must have an SSD, should have extremely high resolution (ended up with 1800p, not 1080p), and only after that did I even bother to check if the machine had at least a decent amount of RAM, and a not entirely terrible CPU. It doesn't even have a dedicated GPU, just the little Intel that can do D3D11 at horrifically low framerates. (This despite using Direct3D SDKs both professionally and for play.)