3 ms·
Multi lingual sounds sexier - tongues FTW... but it definitely doesn't communicate the idea that you can speak 6 to 12 languages. Multi lingual people usually i
by bambalapitiya 12y ago
Multi lingual sounds sexier - tongues FTW... but it definitely doesn't communicate the idea that you can speak 6 to 12 languages. Multi lingual people usually implies people who are naturally competent in language learning and may have a mother and father tongue plus another one or two learned languages. Polyglot on the other hand implies someone who has made it their life's work to speak many many more languages and take all their language beyond a high school level of proficiency at that. And
making sense and being understood, in a very specific way, is the art of speaking a language, so I'd argue it's fitting that these type of people have deliberately identified another word to describe them. Also the syllables of "poly" and "glot" allude to a much deeper, almost poetic, and definitely masterful level of understanding of language. Polloi being the the greek root of many and also glotta being an adjoining word for "having a tongue". The sound glot is onomatopeic too as you have to use your tongue to successfully sound it... and simply the conjugation and associated meanings thus imply a mastery of pronunciation and not just meaning.
So, to counter your mild objection to the sound, I would say it does communicate more. (Honestly, I find myself surprised that I had so much to say about the difference too!)
Re: your idea... I like the idea of it being run by language teachers for language learners ... but do you think people learn languages best from RosettaStone type products? I think they are like gyms - they make money from everyone's intention to speak a language / get fit, rather than support people's actual learning and development. I learned french for years at school but any passion for learning it never really sunk in until I was actually in France. And I've learned portuguese through one to one lessons in person, over skype and by travelling. And I've done audiobooks and apps to keep it alive in my mind when I'm not able to learn first hand... but I don't think I could actually learn a new language without speaking to an actual speaker person. Point is, I think you learn a language faster with a stronger need to be understood.
- LeadingQuestion 12y agoTotally agree they needed a term, or at least _I_ would have wanted one myself as the community formed (although I do like "enthusiast"). >The sound glot is onomatopeic too as you have to use your tongue to successfully sound it... Yes, but the tongue is key to almost all sounds and "poetic"??! To those who primarily know the greek, perhaps, but it's really a gloppy plop of a sound in Amerenglish, in particular. "Polyglossians" would not have been an issue. Plurilinguals. Multiphonauts. Anything but "glot" as it is pronounced in any of my dialects, would give more euphony. ------------------------------------------------------ > but do you think people learn languages best from RosettaStone type products? No!!!! A thousand times no. Nothing at all like that. That seems mainly to be a Gym membership, as you say. (Benny the Irish polyglot's review is among the least negative ones I can respect). My platform and tools are NOTHING Rosetta-like. ------------------------------------------------------ J'aimerais bien aussi savoir ce que vous voulez dire par "beyond a high school level of proficiency" puisque, eh... I know nothing of that consensus. Nor whether you mean the level non-natives are taught if they learn a foreign language in high school, or the level of language mastery high-schoolers in the US have over US English. Personally, I go depth first (I want to write/explain/discuss technical things with technical people, and speak the other registers too. I start from production (writing and speaking). And I have tools for both the art and the science. How's your syntax vs your accent and intonation mimicry? I am on my way to musical fluency in all of the sounds the pulmino-voco-nasal wood/meatwind can produce, as a side project (I am a recently self-identified musician) and am bent to master as many idiolects (mimicry) and dialects and languages as I come across, in multiple different voice characters. I figure it's the right thing to do, since I know of no other people doing so. I am a member of the "polyglot community" but I choose not to use the consensus name. I'm glad you know French. Francophonie is among the words I built "Omniphonic" around. So yeah... Really, I think everyone should try to be sesquilingual, at least. I'm an aspiring omniphonist: an omniphonic enthusiast, anyway, building some delicious dogfood to eat for us all. RE "high-school level"... my minimum comfort level in a new language would be "can explain what you've done and why, and what you've learned doing it so far in life, in twenty minutes, and why that's led to what you're choosing to do/learn now. Then, asking follow-up questions as necessary/interested, can get the same level of detail on those things from the person you're talking with, trying to imagine things as if you'd grown up in their shoes."
- cafard 12y agoI offer you free of charge the term Champolyglot for one who has signed up for Rosetta Stone and never followed through.
- LeadingQuestion 12y agoUh... OK. Thanks! Etymology = as in "you're a champ for not wasting time on a kluge that would delay your real acquisition" or....? Not sure I've got it.