2 ms·
For the problem as stated here ("I'll open one of the other doors to reveal a goat") you should switch doors. For the version of the problem where the host doe
by cperciva 19y ago
For the problem as stated here ("I'll open one of the other doors to reveal a goat") you should switch doors.
For the version of the problem where the host doesn't know where the car is ("I'll open one of the other doors, but I don't know what it will reveal"), it makes no difference.
For the version of the problem where the host knows where the car is and only opens another door if the car is behind the door you picked, you should obviously never change doors.
Usually when this problem is asked, the questioner (who usually doesn't understand the problem himself) doesn't specify which version of the problem he's asking about -- all of the cases I know where a famous smart guy has answered "incorrectly" come down to the problem not being described to them in precise terms and them not making the same assumptions about the host's behaviour as the questioner.