3 ms·
It's clear that both open and closed office plans have their advantages and disadvantages. Ditto hot desking. I'm surprised that no hybrid solution to this pro
by rl3 12y ago
It's clear that both open and closed office plans have their advantages and disadvantages. Ditto hot desking.
I'm surprised that no hybrid solution to this problem exists, or at least one that's taken hold. The best solution we currently have seems to be giving everyone a private office and augmenting it with really good team collaboration software. In most cases however, this does not eliminate the need for direct human collaboration, which is partly why open office plans exist in the first place.
It seems you could accomplish a hybrid approach by somehow giving each employee the ability to toggle the privacy of their workspace on or off. How you would accomplish that remains an interesting question. Some ideas that come to mind:
a) Have two physical workspaces for the employee: one private, one open.
b) Some sort of The Jetsons-esque enclosure around the workspace that can be toggled. Might use technologies such as electronic smart glass (for privacy) and/or active noise cancellation.
c) Have two floors and lifts under each desk. Want privacy? Just ascend or descend into it. It could even support hot desking on both floors, provided the proper visual cues and safety features existed. The cool part about this approach is it could in theory make moving your desk much easier.
d) In the future it could just be a matter of telling your standard ocular and cochlear implants to filter your peripheral vision and hearing accordingly.
Disclaimer: Some of these are admittedly crazy.
- GFischer 12y agoIn "Peopleware", Tom de Marco tries to solve the problem, based on Christopher Alexander's observations: http://javatroopers.com/Peopleware.html#Chapter_13 http://javatroopers.com/Peopleware.html#Chapter_13 Edit: see also the discussion at http://c2.com/cgi/wiki?PeoplewareOnSharedSpaces http://c2.com/cgi/wiki?PeoplewareOnSharedSpaces His first rule is that there is no "one-size-fits-all" solution :) but there are patterns :) He does identify the need for all three of - a communal space - a semiprivate/team space ("war rooms", etc) - a private space Also: "Each team needs identifiable public and semiprivate space and each individual needs protected private space. "