4 ms·
Cap and trade is stupid. It's a form of "carbon credits" designed to create a market for the likes of wall street while allowing for politics to also play a rol
by phkahler 12y ago
Cap and trade is stupid. It's a form of "carbon credits" designed to create a market for the likes of wall street while allowing for politics to also play a role. The simplest thing to do is TAX the carbon coming out of the ground (oil or coal) or coming into the country. This cost will automatically be passed on to whomever uses that fuel in direct proportion to how much the use. However, we continue to subsidize some carbon producers, so you can clearly see that reducing emissions is NOT the primary agenda here.
- Angostura 12y agoI think that climate change is the most important issue facing humanity. I think we will all have to see lower economic growth if our civilisation is to survive. However, I think slapping a straight tax on would be quite disastrous. There are some high carbon industries that going to be vital in the short and medium term, and simply closing them over night, as a flat rate tax is likely to do, is not the way to get our economy to adjust.
- Shivetya 12y agoAlarmist aren't we. Lower economic growth, better try your bets elsewhere because unless you can suddenly remove a third of the population from the planet we ain't going anywhere but up. Energy production will simply shift to what is the most affordable and don't expect it to ever become less than today. If anything our energy expenditures will continue to climb. The only change will be how we create it. When cheaper energy becomes available expect usage to dramatically spike, if anything our biggest threat won't be carbon, it will be heat; waste heat.
- Retric 12y agoCarbon tax can be vary effective while having minimal impact. The important point is it causes conservation in the most economically efficient way possible, carbon credits even with a significantly lower tax rate are far more harmful. The real issue is there is less to lobby about just rate and what to do about imports /exports.
- jshen 12y agoI don't think your conclusion follows from your other points. The people pushing for this may very well have emissions reduction as their primary goal, but they are in a system that forces the solution to something like this.
- rayiner 12y agoThe issue with taxing carbon out of the ground is that it doesn't address what is really relevant: carbon being released into the atmosphere. For example, under a carbon tax, there would be no incentive to research something like carbon capture systems. As for the issue with Wall Street: it would be good to create a market and get Wall Street involved. The politics surrounding Wall Street's involvement in say oil is classic populist dreck: they hate paying more for gas, so they blame "oil speculators" rather than acknowledging the oil traders are just helping the market price-in the fact we're in an era where new oil discoveries come in a firm that's expensive to exploit.
- Retric 12y agoYou can always have a seperate credit for sequestration. However, none of the proposedNlong term systems are anywhere close to being as cost effective as going from coal to wind power.
- throwaway_yy2Di 12y agoMore to the point: a carbon tax introduces price certainty, which (naively) allows efficient long-term planning. (Carbon caps set volume by fiat; carbon taxes set price by fiat. The other variable floats with the market). You can look at the EU carbon market's total failure as an example. It's a cap system, where the price collapsed almost immediately, and so to date it has had zero effect of any sort [0]. The cap right now is way above what the market actually wants. It's useless. The opposite -- price overshoots because of a too tight cap + demand inelasticity -- could also be a really bad thing. Both directly from the pain it causes, and indirectly from the predictable political backlash, which would screw up something else in a new & more creative way. [0] http://www.economist.com/node/21548962 http://www.economist.com/node/21548962
- smsm42 12y agoI'm not sure - how arbitrarily setting prices introduces certainty? Today the Congress or EPA decides the price is X, tomorrow Republicans take the Congress and the presidency and appoint the head of EPA which drops the price to Y, then next cycle Democrats take the power and rise the price to Z, etc. etc. - where's certainty in that? I don't see any objective way of setting such taxes, and as such - any reason why they would be stable is the price is purely arbitrary and thus subject to political games.
- throwaway_yy2Di 12y agoWell it doesn't, no. IF you have stable government policies, than a carbon tax would be a predictable cost, where a cap would be highly volatile. Obviously if the policies are changing too, then you can't predict much of anything. "I don't see any objective way of setting such taxes," How about: estimate the economic damage of a marginal kg of CO2 (external cost), and set the tax equal to that? [0] As an order-of-magnitude guess: [total climate change damage] / [total CO2 emitted], both discounted to present dollars. Not an economist. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax
- bastawhiz 12y ago
- wpietri 12y agoI would personally rather see a carbon tax; it'd be simpler. But I see three big differences with cap and trade that make it more practical. One is that a cap-and-trade program acknowledges the status quo. There are a lot of businesses that are currently emitting CO2, and saying, "Surprise! Big tax for you!" will generate enormous political resistance. If I understand cap-and-trade programs rightly, we'd start out by giving those businesses the right to keep emitting, but let them sell the right if they aren't using it. Suddenly they have choices, turning the response from, "Rawr! Tax bad!" to "Hm, can I get a competitive advantage from this?" The second is that in cap-and-trade, the right price for carbon flows not from government fiat, but from market outcomes. What's the right level for a carbon tax to drive the right amount of reduction 15 years out? Hard to say. Cap and trade lets us fix what we care about, the reductions, and then lets market mechanisms work out how to do that most economically. The third comes from the combination of the first two. The US right is fervently anti-tax, and has been for decades. They are, however, pro-market, at least nominally. Plus, Wall Street loves anything market-like, as it gives them an opportunity to make a buck. A carbon tax will be fought hard by the people facing it before, during, and after. But markets mean winners and losers, and the opportunity for a lot of capitalist reindeer games.