4 ms·
Clearly math isn't your strong suit. An order of magnitude change is nothing minor. It would take the 32% chance and make it a 3.2% chance. Maybe you don't kn
by ars 12y ago
Clearly math isn't your strong suit.
An order of magnitude change is nothing minor. It would take the 32% chance and make it a 3.2% chance.
Maybe you don't know that ^ means to the power off?
- abritishguy 12y agoAnd clearly it isn't your's either.
- judk 12y agoBut only a few years of difference with Moore's Law... Which was the point of the article.
- ars 12y agoYou probably mean: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kryder's_Law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kryder's_Law
- lindenr 12y agoDoes this mean that a 10^13 reliability has 320% chance of failure? EDIT: in any case the correct calculation should be http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=%281-%2810^-14%29%29^%288*4*1024^4%29 http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=%281-%2810^-14%29%29^%2... which gives a 30% chance of failure, versus http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=%281-%2810^-15%29%29^%288*4*1024^4%29 http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=%281-%2810^-15%29%29^%2... for a 3.5% chance.
- ars 12y ago320% would mean you find 3 wrong bits each time you read the disk. I was calculating the expected number of wrong bits per full read of the drive. You calculated the chance of a perfect read which is similar but not the same.
- lindenr 12y agoAh, I see. Could you edit your post to reflect this? As it stands it is very easy to misinterpret.
- ars 12y agoYou can only edit for a little over an hour, and it's been three. I thought "of one bit being wrong" said it, but I can see how you misread it. Hopefully people will read the thread and see these replies as well.
- tedsanders 12y agoHey, please remember to be kind to everyone. Even if you disagree with someone, insulting them adds no value for them and adds no value for the other readers on HackerNews. Insults are the rare type of comment that add value for only a single user. Even if someone is wrong, remember: we're all human. :)
- ars 12y agoI know, you're right. I was just a bit annoyed at his tone so I reacted instead of just replied. I tried to soften it a bit by adding if perhaps he just didn't recognize the notation, but I guess it wasn't enough.
- logicallee 12y agoI did recognize it, ars. I think it's hilarious that if 100000000000000 (1e14) isn't enough reliability then 1000000000000000 (1e15) should do it. As mentioned if you look at, for example, the change from normal bit flips (from cosmic rays) on normal RAM, versus that on ECC RAM, you would see many orders of magnitude. Given that we're speaking about errors (which have a huge standard deviatoin anyway) it is quite normal to see orders of magnitude difference. A factor of 10x is just not that big of a wish, if the error levels are causing you problems! I also don't think that multiplying by the size of the drive is relevant to anything. It doesn't increase the chance you have an error in a specific application, etc. What can you fill 4 TB with, that you wouldn't use software error correction on, but for which a single bit flip is unacceptable? I can think of things like movies, raw sensor data, and other media. I don't see how multiplying by the size of the drive gives you an interesting result. You've just fallen for marketing :)
- ars 12y ago> should do it. They actually sell 10^15 disks, so there is no excuse for 10^14 ones to exist anymore. They aren't even using more error correction to get it - they are binning drives and the better ones get sold for more. This would be fine is the lower spec'd ones were still reasonable, but for a 4TB drive 10^14 is NOT OK, and they should not be selling them anymore.
- logicallee 12y agoI have now spelled it out for you. "Reliability of 100000000000000 is unacceptable! I need exactly 1000000000000000 of reliability (a factor 10 differnece only)." It's hilariously specific. If your error rate is riding up against your usage so that you notice it, you wouldn't expect to just want to cut it by a small factor like that.
- ars 12y ago> It's hilariously specific. The reason for the number is very simple: It actually exists.
- logicallee 12y agoI think it's probably just marketing. They're just engineering reliability targets, a specific batch could have far different rates.