7 ms·
800 Years Of Human Sacrifice In Kent
- canjobear 12y agoThere is so much ambiguity in archeological finds. I buy the evidence here that these bodies were disposed of disrespectfully and publicly. But how do we know it was religious sacrifice? Maybe these were criminals and this was a standard punishment. This was millenia ago in a culture that didn't write anything down. Who knows what anything was like then? To fill in the gaps we end up using our own modern biases and narratives. We like to think we're better and more rational than people in the past, so we attribute these mutilated bodies to a motive that we've moved on from (ritual sacrifice), rather than a motive we still have (judicial execution). To be fair, ritual sacrifice did happen in some cultures and was well documented, but who knows what was going on in this case?
- ars 12y agoThis could also have been a disposal pit for cursed sick people - perhaps they believed that by putting them in this particular spot they could not transfer the curse to anyone? That would explain why some bones more placed there after death. There could be a ton of reason to do this, I too don't buy that this is sacrifice.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoMy mother who studied archaeology told me that her professor said it once up-front that when they don't have any clue what purpose something served, it's often labelled as used for religious reasons.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nl 12y agoThere are no recorded instances (AFAIK) of any behaviours like that in Britain in that time period. OTOH we do know human sacrifice was practiced. [1] and [2] give a reasonable overview of what we do know. Beware that there is some attempt to manufacture a controversy over human sacrifice in Britain. The Celts didn't keep written records of their practices, and Roman records are often interpreted as propaganda. In my view, the combination of archaeological records[3] with the fact that those digs match the Roman records fairly well makes a compelling case. [1] http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/ancient/british_prehistory/human_sacrifice_01.shtml http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/ancient/british_prehistory/huma... [2] http://news.nationalgeographic.com.au/news/2009/03/090320-druids-sacrifice-cannibalism_2.html http://news.nationalgeographic.com.au/news/2009/03/090320-dr... [3] eg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindow_Man#Interpretation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindow_Man#Interpretation
- Detrus 12y agoUSA had documented lynchings six decades ago and those would be considered "sacrifices." No historian should really believe we are better and more rational, just lucked into different circumstances. Judicial executions and ritual sacrifices were often mixed together as they both served social functions. In Rome's arenas, newly captured foreign tribesmen would be "sacrificed" in games along with local criminals.
- subdane 12y agoYour point that lynching is just "ritual sacrifice" by a different name is valid. But I doubt the lynched would agree we lucked into better circumstances.
- mraison 12y agoInteresting read, but I too would love to know more about how archeological conclusions are drawn. For example I may be too picky but I'm always suspicious when I see percentages used for analyzing a sample of 25 individuals. In my opinion 36% local 32% southern Norway or Sweden 20% western Mediterranean 12% indeterminate would be better stated as: 9 local 8 southern Norway or Sweden 5 western Mediterranean 3 indeterminate
- SoftwareMaven 12y agoAny judicial execution of a six year old would be nearly indistinguishable from ritualistic killing, IMO. The reasoning that, "they were outsiders, so they were killed" (whatever the guise of the killing) seems to match humans today pretty well, too (unfortunately).
- danohuiginn 12y agoIt is pretty ambiguous. But I think the reason to believe in religious sacrifice is because there are also animals and other valuables there. The arrangement of the bones should tell you whether an animal has been killed and buried whole, vs. eaten. If you're burying sheep without eating them, religion seems more likely.
- tomc1985 12y agoWhat do they mean by barrows? A pit in the ground?
- w_t_payne 12y agoTL;DR Margate only slightly stranger 4000 years ago than it is today.
- trevmckendrick 12y agoAnother reminder of the dangers of religion. I believe one day people will look back on us with the same horror for preventing gay marriage, premarital sex, etc., as we do the past for things like human sacrifice.
- UweSchmidt 12y ago"Future people will agree with me." We probably do not currently look back with horror to the things that those people from old Kent thought we'd look back in horror to. Instead we judge these people according to our current standards, just as future people will judge us to their standards, which we would probably find quite revolting if we could grasp them at all.
- trevmckendrick 12y agoPg said it better than I can: http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html
- nl 12y agoI downvoted you for a number of reasons, none of which are what PG are talking about. Basically, I think your comment lacked perspective. All cultures have taboos and rites. It is extremely difficult to predict how they will change in the future. For example, the ancient Greeks had no taboo against homosexuality (indeed, it was considered normal), but they also had nothing against keeping slaves. The US as a nation has no taboo against advertising to children, and yet attitudes to homosexuality vary dramatically by region. Extreme violence in films is considered taboo in most cultures, and yet entertaining in the US. Racism is publicly decried in the US, and yet remains ingrained in some other countries. Eating dogs is taboo in the US, not in other countries. Bacon is considered a delicacy in the US, and taboo in many countries. Sometimes religion is the carrier of some of these taboos and rites, and sometimes it is not. Sometimes religion innoculates a culture against a particular practice (eg, Halal means alcoholism isn't a big problem in Muslim countries), and other times it is used to both justify it and to fight it (eg the changing Christian attitude to Slavery). I suspect you'd be better off justifying your post rather than complaining about persecution of downvotes.
- kimonos 12y agoVery interesting article!