3 ms·
Have computers and software progressed that much since the Deep Blue days? I didn't realize that chess has pretty much been solved now. Are computers really tha
by StavrosK 12y ago
Have computers and software progressed that much since the Deep Blue days? I didn't realize that chess has pretty much been solved now. Are computers really that much better than people nowadays?
- Bootvis 12y agoThe computer is incredibly strong and there is no interest for a Man again Computer match but I wouldn't say it's close to being solved or that it's impossible to make further progress for three reasons: 1) Computer vs Computer can still go both ways so clearly the one chess engines make mistake others can exploit; 2) Some sequences are still hard find for computers, e.g. [1]. The long king walk by White is beyond the horizon of the computer. 3) Computer + Man against Computer + Man correspondence matches do benefit from human intervention. [1]: http://www.chessgames.com/perl/chessgame?gid=1124533&kpage=5 http://www.chessgames.com/perl/chessgame?gid=1124533&kpage=5
- Isofarro 12y agoStockfish has been available for quite a while, and over the last few years has been recognised as being the strongest open-source chess engine. It's fantastic to see it take on the best commercial engines toe-to-toe and come out on top. These ratings are computer ratings, and because they are playing very much isolates (computers vs other computers), without enough external human encounters, the ratings are consistent within the computer sphere, but not really like-for-like with human rating lists. A lot has happened since Deep Blue - that was just a 6 game match, which really only proved that machines can play near a grandmaster level, but without nerves. And at times that is good enough to beat a world champion in match conditions, because the human is more susceptible to the psychological events. Since Deeper Blue we've seen the emergence of chess engines on personal computers (rather than racks and racks of RS6000 mid-range servers), so Chess Genius, Fritz, Shredder, Junior, Rybka, Houdini and now Stockfish pushing chess engines ahead. The Chess Genius - Junior levels show chess engines capable of matching grandmasters at blitz/active-play speeds, but still struggling at slower time controls. Rybka onwards show a computer engine where elite grandmasters are seriously challenged. Chess hasn't been solved. Just watching Magnus Carlsen's play shows we are expanding chess knowledge incrementally one game at a time. Yes, progress has slowed down, but the incremental improvement are still there. Chess technique is refined to such a super high degree, but still far short of "solving chess". Perhaps this current generation can beat grandmasters when psychological factors are minimised, it's hard to tell. It's certainly not as clear cut as a Porsche vs Usain Bolt over 100 meters.
- NhanH 12y agoThat's a surprise to me. I've always thought that the reason we stopped having computer vs grandmaster is that the computer will just beat the grandmaster absolutely.
- codehotter 12y agoIn 2006, Deep Fritz 10 beat Kramnik (then world champion) with a score of 4-2 [1] On the Computer Chess Rating List, Stockfish is currently about 350 elo points stronger than Deep Fritz 10. [2] That means Stockfish would have about 88% chance of winning vs Deep Fritz 10. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human%E2%80%93computer_chess_matches#Kramnik_.E2.80.93_Deep_Fritz_.282006.29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human%E2%80%93computer_chess_ma... [2] http://www.computerchess.org.uk/ccrl/4040/rating_list_all.html http://www.computerchess.org.uk/ccrl/4040/rating_list_all.ht...
- Isofarro 12y agoA six game match is not a statistically significant set of data. And Deep Fritz hasn't played many humans in those 8 years since. The Deep Fritz on the rating list, is that the same Deep Fritz that played Kramnik? (Notably the hardware and software version used may be different - perhaps the Deep Fritz on the rating list is weaker than the one that played Kramnik?) And also, be careful trying to compare computer-list Elo with human-list Elo. Because participants on both lists are isolated from each other, there is a tendency for one set of ratings to be inflated/deflated compared to the other. We see this in international chess where countries that don't have regular FIDE tournaments, players either seem to be significantly stronger or significantly weaker than the prevailing norms in the bigger pool of players. South Africa, Myanmar are two such examples.
- letstryagain 12y agoYou are correct, top computers beat any human player today. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human%E2%80%93computer_chess_matches http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human%E2%80%93computer_chess_ma...
- 12y ago