5 ms·
I bet it would be unnerving for someone like Kasparov or Magnus Carlsen to play this program, where it would have 1 minute on the clock and they could have the
by EGreg 12y ago
I bet it would be unnerving for someone like Kasparov or Magnus Carlsen to play this program, where it would have 1 minute on the clock and they could have the whole day. It would make many of the moves in under a second and they'd be better than the grandmasters' moves!
- radicalbyte 12y agoIt wouldn't surprise me if the top players regularly played against the best algorithms as part of their training.
- _flag 12y agoIt's actually not that common. Players will use chess engines to analyze positions, but they will rarely play against them because it doesn't provide realistic practice for an actual chess match. For example, it may be reasonable to play an aggressive variation against an opponent because you think they might have difficulty finding a response in time pressure, but a computer can make precise calculations in any situation, and so such a strategy almost always backfires. What's more, chess is often abstracted at higher levels in terms of things like long term plans ("I want to put pressure on the c7 pawn and control c6") instead of concrete material gains, which allows players to make progress even in positions where there are no direct threats and no sensible exchanges of pieces. Computers when faced with such situations will know that the position is objectively drawn and so will just shuffle their pieces around aimlessly, and playing against this kind of thing is not very good practice for actual human opponents who will try to find ways to beat you anyway.
- Isofarro 12y agoOnly realistic if they were preparing for some sort of Man vs Computer tournament. Computers don't play like humans, and they are consistent in their weaknesses as well as their strengths. As players are more exposed to playing against various chess programs, they learn what positions computers are not so good at (long-range strategical themes, beyond the typical move horizon). A local optimisation, of sorts. So players start adopting an anti-computer style of play, which requires a different mind set to pull off. That in turn affects their natural style of play. So I argue the opposite, for preparing for top-flight tournaments, players probably avoid / severely limit playing against chess engines, to avoid this natural anti-computer bias to their play. Sure, the engines are good for checking variations and analysis, as an assistant. But not as a leader, nor as an opponent.
- halfcat 12y agoOlympic sprinters do not practice racing against race cars. Maybe for a publicity stunt. But not for improvement.
- StavrosK 12y agoHave computers and software progressed that much since the Deep Blue days? I didn't realize that chess has pretty much been solved now. Are computers really that much better than people nowadays?
- Bootvis 12y agoThe computer is incredibly strong and there is no interest for a Man again Computer match but I wouldn't say it's close to being solved or that it's impossible to make further progress for three reasons: 1) Computer vs Computer can still go both ways so clearly the one chess engines make mistake others can exploit; 2) Some sequences are still hard find for computers, e.g. [1]. The long king walk by White is beyond the horizon of the computer. 3) Computer + Man against Computer + Man correspondence matches do benefit from human intervention. [1]: http://www.chessgames.com/perl/chessgame?gid=1124533&kpage=5 http://www.chessgames.com/perl/chessgame?gid=1124533&kpage=5
- Isofarro 12y agoStockfish has been available for quite a while, and over the last few years has been recognised as being the strongest open-source chess engine. It's fantastic to see it take on the best commercial engines toe-to-toe and come out on top. These ratings are computer ratings, and because they are playing very much isolates (computers vs other computers), without enough external human encounters, the ratings are consistent within the computer sphere, but not really like-for-like with human rating lists. A lot has happened since Deep Blue - that was just a 6 game match, which really only proved that machines can play near a grandmaster level, but without nerves. And at times that is good enough to beat a world champion in match conditions, because the human is more susceptible to the psychological events. Since Deeper Blue we've seen the emergence of chess engines on personal computers (rather than racks and racks of RS6000 mid-range servers), so Chess Genius, Fritz, Shredder, Junior, Rybka, Houdini and now Stockfish pushing chess engines ahead. The Chess Genius - Junior levels show chess engines capable of matching grandmasters at blitz/active-play speeds, but still struggling at slower time controls. Rybka onwards show a computer engine where elite grandmasters are seriously challenged. Chess hasn't been solved. Just watching Magnus Carlsen's play shows we are expanding chess knowledge incrementally one game at a time. Yes, progress has slowed down, but the incremental improvement are still there. Chess technique is refined to such a super high degree, but still far short of "solving chess". Perhaps this current generation can beat grandmasters when psychological factors are minimised, it's hard to tell. It's certainly not as clear cut as a Porsche vs Usain Bolt over 100 meters.
- _flag 12y agoYou can watch Magnus Carlsen play a chess program on his phone here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pNvVWeHZG00 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pNvVWeHZG00 As you can tell from his commentary, he thinks the machine is rather stupid (and he is winning after the opening) but the machine is a much better calculator than he is and when the situation becomes more concrete he has to force a draw. Of course, the computer on his phone is considerably worse than the best chess engines, but top chess players generally consider computers to be excellent calculators but dumb in terms of general strategy.
- ars 12y ago> but top chess players generally consider computers to be excellent calculators but dumb in terms of general strategy. Is computer assisted chess a thing? Perhaps with standardized hardware, but any software. In chess I'm good at strategy but terrible at calculating and I miss obvious stuff all the time in my fight for strategy. I always thought I'd do great with computer assistance to look for the obvious stuff, and me telling the computer the long term strategy.
- Bootvis 12y agoIt is. See Centaur chess[1] and correspondence chess. In correspondence chess people don't use standardized hardware (people will probably cheat anyway) but in Centaur chess this can be done. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Chess http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Chess
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- _flag 12y ago> Is computer assisted chess a thing? It was called Advanced Chess [1], now it's sometimes referred to as Centaur Chess. You can find online servers to play this kind of thing but it's mostly just a sort of curiosity. Computer-human pairs are well known to be better than just computers at chess though. 1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Chess http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Chess
- 12y ago
- modernerd 12y ago“I find playing against computers depressing. I don’t like losing. I also think it's not so useful practise. Even though computers have become more human in their style ... it doesn't help you too much in preparation for playing humans (which are still my main opponents).” — Magnus Carlsen, in an interview with Peter Thiel at the Churchill Club: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZBnSU-LX1ss&t=23m51s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZBnSU-LX1ss&t=23m51s