5 ms·
"No we never got any concerns from Snowden"... (months later) "Oh here it is, an email from Snowden"... "So how do you explain that you lied before?" (silen
by rdtsc 12y ago
"No we never got any concerns from Snowden"...
(months later)
"Oh here it is, an email from Snowden"...
"So how do you explain that you lied before?"
(silence)
Is NSA just lying because it hopes the problem will go away? I guess that is not unreasonable. Public has a pretty short attention span. So rather than trying to engage just brush off and deny everything.
Was anyone at the NSA ever punished for lying to the public or Congress? If not they have exactly 0 incentive for not doing it. The part of "Oh yeah here is the email" and the follow up question of "Why were you lying?" quite often never comes. Everyone just moves on.
Looking at the organization as a whole and comparing to a person, NSA acts like a psychopath that climbed its way up to into a power position. Lying through its teeth. Engaging in illegal activities. Every time they are caught, telling lies, they follow up with more lies. Spy on Congress members and judges. Presumably to be able to manipulate them. This is a person you'd want to run away from in real life as fast as possible. They are dangerous because they have power and they have no morals.
- jonnybgood 12y agoWell, from the looks of it Snowden was asking a procedural question, not outlying any concerns. He also received a response. I have to wonder if you actually read the email.
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoYou've missed the point. If that's all there is, why lie about it. Their lying is becoming obsessive. They have no credibility to believe that there are no more Snowdon emails. The content of this one email isn't relevant.
- jonnybgood 12y agoWhat was the lie exactly? Snowden asked the General Counsel a procedural question. As far as we know, Snowden never brought any legal concerns to superiors or otherwise concerning the classified programs of the NSA. And in that regard, the NSA may not be lying. Simply put, if the NSA did not receive concerns from Snowden on the legality of the classified programs, then the NSA is not lying.
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoAgain, the content of the email they produced isn't the point. That they spent much of a year denying any such emails existed is. Also, you're assuming their statement that this is the only email is true. By now, everthing they say, imply, or don't say must be suspect.
- ChrisAntaki 12y ago> The NSA’s new discovery of written contact between me and its lawyers - after more than a year of denying any such contact existed - raises serious concerns. ^ Something Snowden says, at the beginning of the article.
- mpyne 12y agoIt's something Snowden claims, but I don't see the justification for it if you actually read Snowden's email. Snowden says his one (instead of multiple emails as he previously claimed) disproved this NSA claim: "after extensive investigation, including interviews with his former NSA supervisors and co-workers, we have not found any evidence to support Mr. Snowden’s contention that he brought these matters to anyone’s attention." But his one email made no such suggestion as bringing any legal matter whatsoever to anyone's attention. It asked whether an E.O. was really at the same level of statute law (it is, it is only the scope of effect that is different). Snowden's email didn't even suggest he had any complaints to make about NSA interpretation of law. If anything it reminded me more of the arguments made by "Freeman on the Land". Snowden claims that other emails do exist though, with actual substantive complaints. But I'm not sure what to believe, if he actually seems to think this email of his represented a formal complaint, then who knows what was actually in his claimed email to the SID Office of Compliance? He also doesn't mention who he sent his email regarding his EO 12333 question to. Was it this very email? Does he expect legal counsel to read minds too? And either way, his complaint was that the activity conducted under EO 12333 was "indefensible", not "illegal". But I don't know of any major organizations (private corporations or public agencies) that would deliberately take a harder route to undertake an activity they were authorized to do.
- ChrisAntaki 12y agoFirst, there was a complete denial, and now magically, an email manifests. That's the point you seem to be missing.
- mpyne 12y agoThere was no complete denial. Does anyone really believe the NSA said "We promise we have never received a single email from Edward Snowden"? He'd probably have to send dozens of emails every day in the normal course of his duties. The NSA did put out a complete denial that he has raised an actual issue with the agency's conduct of their intelligence programs, and this email doesn't contradict that line one bit. There may be such emails out there (Snowden claims there's at least one), but this isn't one of them. I mean, otherwise NSA wouldn't have released it.
- Create 12y agoSo why is this significant? Well, this guy’s name is John Poindexter, and he’s incidentally the guy who was found to be most responsible for the Iran-Contra scandal. He was convicted of lying to Congress but then never went to jail. And in 2001, he started a Government program called ‘Total Information Awareness’. He made a speech when he announced the program, where he said that “…data must be made available in large-scale repositories with enhanced semantic content for easy analysis”. http://privacy-pc.com/news/changing-threats-to-privacy-moxie-marlinspike-on-privacy-threats-at-defcon-part-2.html http://privacy-pc.com/news/changing-threats-to-privacy-moxie...
- mpyne 12y ago> "So how do you explain that you lied before?" (silence) Given that the email they showed does not represent a change to their story (that they never received an emailed concern from Snowden) I'm not sure that it's obvious it was a lie. After all, Snowden's question was purely procedural, not a pronouncement of wrongdoing of any sort. The most action you'd possibly expect to be taken as a result of that email is that NSA's internal training adds a footnote to the hierarchy of authorities slide. > Was anyone at the NSA ever punished for lying to the public or Congress? The man who lied to Congress is the DNI, not a member of the NSA, and his testimony was a designed sandbagging: He could be charged with an actual crime no matter which answer he had given, so I'm not surprised that the DOJ isn't racing to proffer charges here, especially since the Senator asking the question both already knew the answer, and knew that he could have given the answer to the public directly, if he wished, since he has Congressional immunity to his comments on the Senate floor. The NSA itself doesn't talk to the public as a rule, so it would be hard to convict members of them of lying in the first place. Their public statements are clearly designed to be at least technically truthful. So I'm concerned then, that this has all become a giant echo chamber: People are fed information and use that to confirm that which they already believe, even when the evidence actually presented is contradictory. I know you're probably trying to vent more than anything but I don't see as a possibility that many people here will be changing their mind any time soon. And I say that as someone who changed my mind; one of my highest-voted comments here was in support of Snowden on the occasion of the first story that popped up, before it became clear that the story being presented wasn't the same as the story as it actually was.
- sixQuarks 12y agoThis is interesting. So you were a Snowden supporter at first, but changed your mind after seeing more evidence. I'd like to know what made you change your mind.
- mpyne 12y agoIt was changed pretty quickly, to be honest. PRISM was announced as a system that could "literally read your thoughts as you type". Greenwald said the NSA had direct, unfettered access to Facebook, Google, etc. So naturally I was pretty concerned about this vast abuse of authority and massive blow against Constitutional freedoms, and expressed as much here on HN. But just reading the NSA slides made it clear that something much different (and far less sinister) was being talked about. They couldn't "read our thoughts" after all. At worst, the system allowed tech companies to automatically package up the data legally obtained through actual warrants or subpoenas, something previously routinely done manually. PRISM even still required the company's manual involvement for each and every single request. The reality was far different from what had been implied, and sometimes even actually stated. Greenwald himself had either lied, or been mislead by someone, and my money was on the latter. But it was Snowden's job to know how PRISM worked and get Greenwald to explain it right. When it turned out that the self-described "career intelligence operative" was... not, I quickly realized that things weren't as they seemed. And then all sorts of excuses started piling on: Oh, PRISM does require a warrant sometimes, but the Court that issues them gives secret rulings (oooh). Never mind that the Court in question was around since 1978, or that no other nation even bothers putting judicial oversight on foreign intelligence. Snowden said he'd have been fine with PRISM with Article III warrants, but when an Article III warrant was duly issued for his own arrest then all of a sudden all U.S. courts were corrupt. And on it goes. And it's turned out that way for almost literally every single leak since. Some claim would be made about the NSA, but then when pressed Snowden or Greenwald would have to admit that the topic being discussed was a capability, but there wasn't evidence of major misuse. Or they'd leave out important context. A lot of this stuff would have been damning in some way on its own, so I could never figure out why the shiftyness was required. When you're debating with the USG and the USG is more honest, that's sad in many ways.