9 ms·
Justin.tv ending archiving, deleting all archived videos after June 14
- protomyth 12y agoA little over a week doesn't seem like enough time for the news to get out and people to download all their content.
- deftnerd 12y agoI'm not a Justin.tv user, but it frustrates me when organizations make big decisions like this without much time for their users to react. I can only assume that they're bleeding money and they're trying to quickly cut their operating costs. Someone should contact the Archive.org and see if they can get copies of all the public archives of these videos.
- tim333 12y agoYeah, 8 days notice isn't much though at least it's better than Yahoo's shutting down Everyblock with no notice at all. I see Everyblock is back under new ownership but I'm not sure they've got the old data.
- taurath 12y agoJustin.tv owns Twitch, which is recently rumored to be in acquisition talks with Youtube for $1bil. I don't think they're bleeding money at this point.
- kevinflo 12y agoBleeding money and being in acquisition talks are not mutually exclusive.
- ajb 12y agoMaybe not, but it's bad strategy to give away that you're bleeding money while in acquisition talks.
- huxley 12y agoAs long as you don't end up like HP and Autonomy: http://www.theguardian.com/business/2013/may/07/shareholders-sue-hp-autonomy-deal http://www.theguardian.com/business/2013/may/07/shareholders...
- ajb 12y agoOops. Yes, you're right - you almost certainly have to disclose it at some point. Don't take legal advice from me...
- jack-r-abbit 12y agoBut... maybe having a huge archive of user videos and being owned by YouTube might be mutually exclusive.
- lost-theory 12y agoPerhaps they want to make this change before the acquisition to spare Google the bad press of "shutting down yet another service".
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bruceb 12y agoSo only 1 week notice? Bit harsh. Seems 30 days would be more standard when shutting a service or feature.
- pgrote 12y agoIt could be a cost elimination.
- niels_olson 12y agoCould be? I'm amazed they were keeping all that video this long.
- bruceb 12y agoI am sure it is and I can understand eliminating this feature but why not give users more warning?
- acdha 12y agoLikely - also, if true, basically the equivalent of putting a banner on their site saying “We don't value our users!”. Even a minimally competent management team should be able to look at the burn rate and make decisions more than a few days out.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pavel_lishin 12y agoI wonder what it would take to transload them all to youtube.
- im3w1l 12y ago>We found that more than half of our VODs are unwatched (with 0 or 1 total views), while the vast majority are rarely watched (with 10 or less views). Isn't this the standard for content? Anyone know similar statistics for image hoster, url minifiers, youtube, appstore etc?
- sp332 12y agoIt seems like they asked the wrong question. It's not about how many people want to watch archived video, it's about how many people want to make an archive of a video. That said, I wonder if the amount of money they save is enough to offset the users they lose to other services.
- jonny_eh 12y agoI think the question they asked was "how much does it cost to host all this video?" Then for their post, they answered the question they wished they were asked, like a politician does in an interview.
- Aqueous 12y agoPerhaps they should just keep the archive videos for a week or a couple of days after the broadcast. That gives a window for users to download archived copies and reduces the amount of storage they need on their end. It also means that users aren't forced to generate video archives themselves, and can still rely on the service for this function. Maybe for videos that accrue a certain amount of unique views during the grace period, keep them around in a sort of "Classics" library?
- ggreenbe 12y agoI like the idea of something like 24hour retention. If you just missed a broadcast by say an hour or live in another timezone +12hours then maybe watching it later within the 24 hour grace period would be good.
- kcbanner 12y agoTwitch.tv uses a similar system
- pronoiac 12y agoFor comparison, Ustream announced a few months ago that they'd only retain archived video for a month for free accounts.
- Asparagirl 12y agoIf the destruction of all this unique user-generated content pisses you off -- and it should -- then feel free to join ArchiveTeam and help save this (and other) content for the Internet Archive. Check out the ArchiveTeam wiki at archiveteam.org, or come on over to #archiveteam and #archiveteam-bs on efnet throughout this week to watch a self-organizing data rescue mission happen in real time. (There will probably be a new dedicated channel spun off for this project later today or tomorrow.) In the meantime, programs like youtube-dl and livestreamer are your friends. http://rg3.github.io/youtube-dl/documentation.html http://rg3.github.io/youtube-dl/documentation.html http://livestreamer.readthedocs.org/en/latest/ http://livestreamer.readthedocs.org/en/latest/
- IvyMike 12y agoTo elaborate, the ArchiveTeam distributes a very simple-to-use virtual machine image that you can run. When you do so, your machine will help download and collect from disappearing websites. I don't think they've got scripts for justin.tv yet, but it sounds like they are going to, so now would be a good time to get your VM ready. It's easy, and the more people who run the machine, the more power the ArchiveTeam has at their disposal. I encourage everyone to give it a look. You can get the virtual machine here: http://tracker.archiveteam.org/ http://tracker.archiveteam.org/
- g_lined 12y agoI downloaded the VM today and spent a fair while trying to diagnose a CheckIP error. It turns out, after going on the IRC channel that none of the projects on the VM are up to date and hence the VM can't be used to help the project. Hence the error. If I see the website update to mention justin.tv I'll certainly fire it up. But it seems a shame that there is nothing I can do to help with their project as a whole; I couldn't even see any way to donate - I guess I should just donate to archive.org.
- Asparagirl 12y agoRight, the idea is that justin.tv could be formatted as a new project for the ArchiveTeam Warrior -- which you can run on your laptop or a VM or a cloud server or a few Amazon instances, or whatever. But with only a week's notice before the shutdown, I don't know whether they can get the customized scripts up and running in time. They're working on extracting a list of user and video id's right now.
- dredmorbius 12y agoTwo week notice for storage policy changes smells like financial concerns to me.
- serf 12y agowell, to be fair, nearly any storage policy change will smell that way.
- dredmorbius 12y agoIt's one thing to say "we're phasing this out over 12 months" (or even, say, six). Two weeks is freaking desperation.
- Paul12345534 12y agoAgreed, 3-6 months notice is fine. This is not a classy way for them to address the issue.
- aleem 12y agoThis is reminiscent of Google's (and others, to be fair) build-first, monetise-later approach to products. Features get cut, entire products get slashed and users end up losing their data and time invested. At least Google had acted partly responsibly by providing ample notice and allowing users to download their data before shutting down Google Reader. In the case of Justin.tv, I would propose they at least take a measured approach and start by deleting videos that haven't received a single view in over a 6 months then work their way from there.
- rhizome 12y agoIn 2007, this was THE FUTURE, where UGC was going to be the democratizing content tide that would lift all of our boats. Turns out it all devolved into ad platforms anyway, just like 1997.
- dylanrw 12y agoI like how they phrase this like it's a considerate product decision, while it's essentially them not wanting to shoulder the expense of storage. Without knowing more about their product internals an immediately obvious and important feature getting the axe from this is highlights. Example: I will stream and then go back the next day and cut the video down and take the snippets and post them to youtube. These highlights then lead to interest in the channel which leads to more viewers. Now I need to archive all my stuff locally, and upload it over my mediocre connection. If they limited the archival time window to 4 hours after the end of the broadcast they would have their drastic reduction in infrastructure cost while not totally removing a valid and arguably important feature.
- kevingadd 12y agoI think that's how Twitch works by default now. They archive the whole stream for like a week so you can Highlight it, and then it's auto-deleted (unless you've configured it to keep everything).
- kevinwang 12y agoI believe the default now is that nothing is saved, not even for a week. However, each user can configure a setting that does cause Twitch to save the stream for about a week, before it's deleted. In order to fully archive a stream "permanently", a user needs to view each archived recording individually and select an option from that page to save it forever.
- Yver 12y agoThe page currently says "All VODs will be removed after June 8, 2014. We recommend downloading your recorded videos before the date."
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- instakill 12y agoThat really isn't a lot of notice.
- jacquesm 12y agoIf they're cutting things this fine I fear for the future of justin.tv, this does not sound like a well thought out corporate move, it sounds like panic. Imagine coming back from your holiday in two weeks time and finding all your stuff wiped out. Ridiculous.
- dtech 12y agoI know Justin.tv and Twitch.tv are related, does anyone know if this policy will also reflect twitch?
- abstractbill 12y agoThe policy will only affect Justin.tv, not Twitch.
- swang 12y agoOf course this is financial. Justin.tv is not a profit center for Twitch Interactive, so they need to cut costs. If 50% of VODs are viewed <= 1 time, and most viewed <=10 times, why not just leave them there? Obviously storing them costs money, but there probably isn't a lot of bandwidth costs associated with it. I don't have anything against what they're doing as much as the sugarcoating of "focusing on live video" This also lends more credence that they're getting bought out soon and want to look good on the cost sheets.
- SoftwareMaven 12y agoand want to look good on cost sheets Ding, ding, ding. We have a winner! Seriously, there can be no explanation for the ridiculously short notice other than YouTube said, "You look good, but your costs are just too high." (Or, if not YouTube, somebody else Twitch is trying to get into a bidding war with YouTube.) Any other reason and management would have looked at the costs and said, "We need to transition out to save money," and provided a reasonable runway for their customers. As it is, this has nothing to do with making things better for their customers.
- ghaff 12y agoOn the one hand, I have a fair bit of sympathy for the preservationist school of though--and the Internet Archive does great work. I also consider it very fortunate that much (though not all) of Usenet was preserved when it may well not have been. OTOH: >We found that more than half of our VODs are unwatched (with 0 or 1 total views), while the vast majority are rarely watched (with 10 or less views). The reality is that there is an increasingly indescribably volume of user-created "stuff" out there and it's pretty impractical to preserve all of it. And when it's not on a well-known site that's shutting down (think Geocities) it mostly sinks beneath the waves without anyone really noticing. I could probably name any number of online magazines/sites which went away or restructured and whose content is no longer available. I'm not saying that's a good thing but it's hard for me to get too worked up in most of these cases.
- chroma 12y agoA few Defcons ago, Jason Scott gave an excellent talk about this failure mode[1]. Basically, companies host user-generated content for free. Then years later, they destroy it with little or even no notice. Sturgeon's law applies; most of the deleted content is crap. But a lot of it matters to the people who made it. More importantly, a small fraction of it is stuff that future historians would kill for. Collectively, companies that engage in this behavior are burning historical evidence. 1. Archive Team: A Distributed Preservation of Service Attack http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-2ZTmuX3cog http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-2ZTmuX3cog
- maxerickson 12y agoI find it hard to get too wound up about an only copy that has been turned over to a third party. I get that the user understanding the situation well can be a problem, but it isn't a very careful thing to do.
- Siecje 12y agoThey should only keep content for a week if there is no views. Having an additional recording is convent, now people have to record locally at the same time as streaming.
- blat001 12y agoI wonder if it is relate to copyright issues associated with the sale of twitch.tv As in Google saying they can't deal with these videos without proper acceptance of their terms of service. The timing seems to indicate they are trying to offload the content ASAP. From a cost perspective, they are already paying for it and 1 week vs 1 month would not make that much of a difference if it was a "product feature"
- dobbsbob 12y agoi only use JTV to nerd out in the trek streaming channels and make fun of rikers lack of beard in chat during season 1 TNG
- Paul12345534 12y agoI understand people need to make business decisions but short notice on something like this isn't exactly a classy move.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- AliAdams 12y agoI don't see why the decision is so digital. Surely a 1 week hold coupled with the ability to move the video to YouTube (or simply the latter as an option at the end of a live stream) would take away the huge hosting costs but give content creators the chance to save certain videos if they wanted to.
- brianbreslin 12y agoIts interesting if you read their FAQ, they are eliminating their premium service which in theory should have included archiving. My first thought was why not charge people for permanent archiving? Guess not enough people are paying to even justify the consumer premium model. I feel like justin.tv's peak was 5+ years ago, twitch seems to have been their real business in the last 3 years.