4 ms·
My son's elementary school homework this week included, after a series of arithmetic exercises involving adding pairs of even numbers, this sequence of question
by jameshart 12y ago
My son's elementary school homework this week included, after a series of arithmetic exercises involving adding pairs of even numbers, this sequence of questions:
What happens when you add together two even numbers?
Is that true for all even numbers?
Why?
Part of me was overjoyed to see an actual mathematical question being posed, but... what exactly was my second grader son expected to write under the 'why' part of the worksheet? There was a couple of inches of blank space left for him to fill in his answer. Is the teacher going to read his answer there and mark is right or wrong and hand back the homework? I don't know if I have much hope that this will be used by the teacher to gauge each child's understanding in order to facilitate further classroom discussion. Have the kids been taught a particular explanation in class which the homework is expecting them to reproduce? What is the teacher's goal in sending home this question as an exercise?
The fact that two even numbers always add up to an even number, as do two odd numbers, is an interesting insight into the shape and flavor of numbers. It gives you a practical tool - you can use this knowledge to parity check mental calculations and intuitively reject wrong answers - as well as an insight into the idea that esoteric mathematical properties numbers have can have interesting consequences when they interact, which is kind of the essence of a lot of mathematical thinking.
Is that always true?
Why?
are probably the most important questions in mathematics. But... I have no idea how you teach that, except by having a one one one conversation with each student about it. I don't think you can get much value out of asking them on a single page worksheet and sending it home as homework, though.
- salgernon 12y agoWe have to reference Tom Lehrer and the New Math era of the 60s: "But in the new approach, as you know, the important thing is to understand what you're doing, rather than to get the right answer." http://www.lyricsfreak.com/t/tom+lehrer/new+math_20138395.html I did new math in the 70s and it did prepare me for understanding unix file permissions. chmod 0755 foo.pl!
- jameshart 12y agoI love Tom Lehrer dearly, but I don't see how it's appropriate here. Do you think that trying to teach kids to understand what they are doing is wrong? Nowhere am I suggesting that I have the impression that the child writing down "When you add two even numbers you always get 7" would be considered a valid answer on this worksheet - clearly they're trying to get kids to comprehend parity. Or are you suggesting that the answer would be different if you were missing two thumbs?
- j2kun 12y agoI really hope your child's teacher doesn't just mark it right or wrong, but provides a counterargument for a flawed answer. The question of "how do you teach one to answer 'why?'" is a difficult one, but here's what I understand is the established way of doing it. You give the student a problem, they think about it for a long time, and give their answers as to why. You discuss their answers with them, and then after they revise their answers, you present an elegant and correct answer. Then you repeat. It's interesting, for example, that nobody asks how to teach one to answer "why" when you're, say, analyzing the motives of a character in some piece of literature. What do they do? They discuss, then they revise, and at some point the teacher presents either a good piece of student work or some other established ideas. Is mathematics really that different just because in the end you can tell with certainty that an answer is correct or incorrect? English teachers have one on one conversations with their students about their work, and they make students have discussions with each other about their thoughts on a daily basis. Why can't math teachers do the same? I think part of the reason math is plagued by such questions is that most people don't realize that a proof (aka the answer to "why?") is not just correct or incorrect, but has aesthetic properties. Nevertheless, it's clear that mathematics is set apart from this on day one. Just compare any high school math syllabus to a syllabus in another subject [1] [1]" http://j2kun.svbtle.com/what-would-math-class-look-like-if-it-were-a-fine-art http://j2kun.svbtle.com/what-would-math-class-look-like-if-i...
- noobermin 12y ago>math is careening towards you and you should brace for impact Hilarious, another great article from Mr. Kun.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y ago> I really hope your child's teacher doesn't just mark it right or wrong, but provides a counterargument for a flawed answer. His son's teacher isn't going to do this. First, she didn't design the question... even if some public school teachers have the capacity to do this, they don't have the time or resources to design curriculums. Second, if she didn't design it, she likely does not have the wit to be able to argue about it without doing research. Third, public schools aren't places where they make time for each student trying to inspire genius, she really is just checking boxes down a list all semester. Fourth, doing so won't improve his scores on a standardized test. Finally, there was only two inches of blank space for the child to write an answer, she definitely isn't going to write him a thesis on the margins of the paper. Public education is blind idiot god, handing down edicts from on high, some dumb and some smart, some sane and others insane, some incomprensible and some not. And often enough, all of these at the same time. The bell will ring, it will be time for a new lesson, and in that one he will be taught to never leave any multiple choice question unanswered because "they unanswered questions are scored just the same as wrong ones, you might as well guess".
- sliverstorm 12y agoThe "Why?" wasn't a prompt for a formal proof, and probably not a prompt to regurgitate what was learned in class. At least back when I was a kid, it was clear to me that "Why?" was a way of forcing the student to think about the problem. To attempt to justify your yes/no answer requires thought, whether or not you are right or wrong! If you only write yes/no, the teacher cannot tell if you actually thought about it or guessed.
- j2kun 12y agoA proof need not be "formal" to be a perfectly good, elegant, insightful proof. For example, one could observe that an even number of quarters can be formed into two rows of the same size, and if you do this with two piles of quarters, you can put the rows together to make two big rows. This is as good as any "formal" proof, and I sincerely hope it's the kind of proof the teacher shows as an example of a good answer.
- jjoonathan 12y agoThe "Why?" question might not be so crazy if the kids had just learned about base 10 addition and if the book defined "even" as "numbers ending in {0,2,4,6,8}". Intuitively, the kids would need to figure out that the digits in the tens, hundreds, etc places don't matter (this is implied by information-flow through the "addition algorithm"). Then it's a simple matter of proving the 5 cases given. If that's actually what they intended, I'm impressed with the material. It plausibly teaches proof-by-cases (real math!) at a very young age, but more importantly it teaches the mathematical skill of using what you know to prove what you want to know. I felt mildly clever after cracking the puzzle, I can only imagine what a grade-schooler would feel. More mathematical self-confidence than they would get from solving a sheet of 100 addition problems, that's for sure! Even if the lesson doesn't "stick" and teach the kids how to use proof-by-cases in general, it looks like a win in my book.
- jameshart 12y agoExactly - I like the idea of trying to get kids to understand the difference between "I can' think of any counterexamples" and "There can't be any counterexamples because I can prove it always works this way". But I think two inches of space on a homework worksheet is probably not enough space for a child of 8 to explain adequately why the latter is true. My suggestion would be that the child should write "I have an elegant proof of this but this worksheet is too small to contain it" in the space...
- kazagistar 12y agoBut really, teaching the 5 cases version is also not quite right. Maybe even numbers are "a bunch of 2s added up" and odd numbers are "a bunch of 2s and a leftover one". Then you just deal with the cases... two bunches of 2s is still a bunch of twos, if you have two of the leftover ones you get another two... The point is, both lines of reasoning are fine. The value comes from having the students struggle through any of many, many ways of explaining it, comparing their answers, and thinking about the aesthetics of the models, and getting a tangible feel on their isomorphism. All of which you can do before needing to even have memorized your multiplication tables. That said, 100 addition problems can be useful: jamming the addition and multiplication tables into your memory so you can do the needed symbol manipulation later. But similarly massive problem sheets for, say, remainders or algebra is just silly.