3 ms·
> The FDA was invented to solve a real problem. No doubt. But that still leaves open a number of questions: 1. Is it a proper role for government to solve th
by mindcrime 12y ago
> The FDA was invented to solve a real problem.
No doubt. But that still leaves open a number of questions:
1. Is it a proper role for government to solve that particular problem?
2. Is the FDA (as we know it) the only possible way to solve that problem?
3. Does solving that problem outweigh the unintended consequences that result from the "solution"?
It's easy to say "Oh hey, there's this problem, let's just pass a law to fix it", but the Real World is often times more complicated than that.
- rosser 12y ago1. Is it a proper role for government to solve that particular problem? Who else is going to? There's no profit in it, so you can't expect someone to do it out of Smith-ian self-interest. And you certainly can't expect the pharma companies to police themselves; they hide studies that clearly show adverse, even deadly side effects, and otherwise outright lie, even with the FDA around. Imagine the hijinks that would ensue without it.
- crazy1van 12y agoIn general, I support your libertarian way of thinking. But on the other hand, drug resistance does have elements of a tragedy of the commons. Its often in our individual best interests to over medicate, but the group as a whole suffers with resistant germs. Just like it is in every individuals best interest to have the best value vehicle despite of the extra pollution that skimping on some components would cause. Then again, this type of thinking can quickly extend too far. Vast numbers of drugs require prescriptions that have nothing to do with antibiotics. Heck, I can't even get contact lenses without a prescription. That kind of thinking strikes of nannyism.