6 ms·
I have no problem with this either. I don't believe it's a proper role for government to regulate what substances people can buy and ingest. I would happily s
by mindcrime 12y ago
I have no problem with this either. I don't believe it's a proper role for government to regulate what substances people can buy and ingest. I would happily shut down the FDA altogether. If you're stupid enough to buy and ingest something poisonous, well... so be it.
Note that none of this is mean to say that sellers should not be held liable for fraud if they ship something other than what they claim to be shipping. But that's a separate issue.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoYou are in the vast minority then. In the bad old days, nothing was certain because there was no standard. Look at China for a modern example of the endemic fraud in food and drugs. The FDA was invented to solve a real problem. Its nothing to do with stupidity - its to do with accountability.
- mindcrime 12y ago> The FDA was invented to solve a real problem. No doubt. But that still leaves open a number of questions: 1. Is it a proper role for government to solve that particular problem? 2. Is the FDA (as we know it) the only possible way to solve that problem? 3. Does solving that problem outweigh the unintended consequences that result from the "solution"? It's easy to say "Oh hey, there's this problem, let's just pass a law to fix it", but the Real World is often times more complicated than that.
- rosser 12y ago1. Is it a proper role for government to solve that particular problem? Who else is going to? There's no profit in it, so you can't expect someone to do it out of Smith-ian self-interest. And you certainly can't expect the pharma companies to police themselves; they hide studies that clearly show adverse, even deadly side effects, and otherwise outright lie, even with the FDA around. Imagine the hijinks that would ensue without it.
- crazy1van 12y agoIn general, I support your libertarian way of thinking. But on the other hand, drug resistance does have elements of a tragedy of the commons. Its often in our individual best interests to over medicate, but the group as a whole suffers with resistant germs. Just like it is in every individuals best interest to have the best value vehicle despite of the extra pollution that skimping on some components would cause. Then again, this type of thinking can quickly extend too far. Vast numbers of drugs require prescriptions that have nothing to do with antibiotics. Heck, I can't even get contact lenses without a prescription. That kind of thinking strikes of nannyism.
- mindslight 12y agoThe problem is that the FDA/DEA went past solving a problem (opt-in), and into restricting behavior (can't opt-out). Testing is good. Market standards and labeling are good. Completely prohibiting sales (by default!) between informed parties is bad. Distribution of new antibiotics should probably be discouraged to avoid breeding resistant strains, but this is a rare exception (notice the title of this article mentions three classes of drugs, yet focuses on the only one that has moral standing). It can also be solved through less heavy-handed methods like manufacturer agreements, rather than an impermissive white list on every area the FDA sees fit for growing their clout.
- codezero 12y agoEven if that's all true, the real issue here is that products are being sold to people who aren't informed about what they are ingesting. The article leads with the author's wife wanting to buy a cream for moderate acne, not severe acne. The cream they sent has potential serious side effects which I doubt are made very clear to the purchaser. People often act on good faith, that is, they buy something assuming it's been tested and is safe. Yes, it's true, we could all spend all day long reading every ingredient on every label and reading all the scholarly research on it, but it's cognitive overload. Having medications evaluated by a trusted source is something many people actually do want, the FDA does serve that role and while it means there are restrictions, I think most people are OK with that. Of course, nothing is true for all people, and there are plenty of places you can go where you can buy any drug you want.
- jchrisa 12y agoYou could have a label "not FDA approved" but require it to be very large and ominous.
- rosser 12y agoBecause warning labels do such a good job of deterring people in other cases.
- codezero 12y agoAnd we have that on a lot of stuff, but I think what I meant in this context is that most people in the US don't expect prescription strength stuff to be available on Amazon, so assume the work has been done for them when they search. Thai pharmaceutical companies aren't likely to include any FDA related disclaimers :P
- aestra 12y agoOh good god... NOT this again. That's already the case with supplements and we know how that turned out... http://www.forbes.com/sites/emilywillingham/2013/11/07/study-herbal-supplements-full-of-contaminants-substitutes-and-fillers/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/emilywillingham/2013/11/07/study... http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/15/opinion/sunday/skip-the-supplements.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/15/opinion/sunday/skip-the-su... http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/05/science/herbal-supplements-are-often-not-what-they-seem.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/05/science/herbal-supplements... http://www.bottomlinepublications.com/content/article/health-a-healing/are-your-herbal-supplements-contaminated-or-fake http://www.bottomlinepublications.com/content/article/health... Oh by the way "the informed consumer" just doesn't happen. 95% of people just grab something off the shelf and expect it to be safe and effective. Even if it isn't.
- peteretep 12y ago> I don't believe it's a proper role for government to > regulate what substances people can buy and ingest Your free-thinkin' Wild-West Libertarian views directly impinge on my right to use antibiotics that work.
- neurobro 12y agoJust don't neglect people's right to store some antibiotics in their preparedness kit without wasting a doctor's scarce time and engaging in medical fraud.
- mindcrime 12y agoYou have the right to use whatever antibiotics you can get your hands on. But you can hardly claim to have a "right" to an antibiotic for every conceivable case, considering that such an antibiotic may not exist yet, or may not even be possible.
- aestra 12y agoDid you miss this part? >are endangering public health, such as by breeding antibiotic resistance. Yeah, because every asshole with a sniffle should not be able to self medicate with antibiotics.
- eksith 12y agoI'll have to disagree on shutting down the FDA. It's purview goes well beyond medication and into medical devices as well as food production, of course. Not having a trusted authority (central or not) to vet and evaluate products for human consumption can return things to the days of Snake Oil. I do agree that the FDA is largely ineffective at preventing people from doing things to their bodies. Ironically, the FDA would probably be able to better serve the public if it switches roles from enforcement to advisement. Keeping food, medication/devices and production methods to FDA standard, I believe, should get a UL type verification for things we use every day. Having that stamp brings trust that the FDA has verified the efficacy of whatever it is you put into your system, however there's nothing preventing you from going non UL if you're aware of the risks. edit_ To the folks downvoting your post, I disagree with them as well!
- glenra 12y agoIt's worth considering that UL certification is an example of what happens when government doesn't regulate - it evolved initially as an entirely free-market mechanism to solve a real problem that regulators hadn't addressed. Get rid of the FDA and something kind of like the UL would probably spring up to replace it. But without the coercion, people would have the option to ignore it when they really need to. Incidentally, some "snake oil" actually works: http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/snake-oil-salesmen-knew-something/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/snake-oil-salesmen...
- Raphael 12y agoThe FDA tests products for purity. You just want to eliminate bans.
- skizm 12y agoThe FDA stops companies from labeling things in a way that is technically correct but misleading. They make companies back up their claims with actual science. You would not be able to make an informed decision without the FDA. Stupid doesn't come into it.
- KVFinn 12y ago>I have no problem with this either. I don't believe it's a proper role for government to regulate what substances people can buy and ingest. I would happily shut down the FDA altogether. If others breed antibiotic resistant bacteria by regularly ordering antiobiotics for acne or whatnot, it doesn't just effect them it effects me.