3 ms·
The value of links split over a portfolio of single-purpose websites is questionable. SEO is a Winner Take Most game, in which having 1% more ranking ability (
by patio11 17y ago
The value of links split over a portfolio of single-purpose websites is questionable. SEO is a Winner Take Most game, in which having 1% more ranking ability (in general, links) than the next guy can result in you getting 50% more traffic, or more, because of how people click the highest positions in the SERP overwhelmingly more. In other words, there is an increasing marginal return on links pointed at the same domain.
Thus, splitting your links over 5 or 50 or 500 properties tends to mean you rank for a LOT less than you would have had you "put your eggs in one basket", even if you get marginally more links in aggregate to the portfolio than you would have gotten to the single site.
The only exception to this which jumps out at me is exact match domains, because they can rank with many, many less links than an identical page on non-exact match domain. (For those who are new to this concept: if your query is exactly [exact match domain], then exactmatchdomain{.com|.net|.org} and a few major country TLDs get an automatic and massive bonus in their rankability for that query and that query alone. My main domain has thousands of links, many from fairly authoritative sources like e.g. google.com. My mini-sites on exact match domains generally start with one link from my blog and outrank the main site within a week or two.)
- dasil003 17y agoThe flaw in your thinking is twofold. First, all searches are not equal. Second, you do not necessarily need those marginal returns. Inbound links do not provide some generic amount of Google juice. Relevance is very important. If you have a focused page, not only will you probably attract more links, but those links will use more relevant search terms and Google will understand the page to be more relevant to the terms as well. Other inbound links for some other service will not have much value at all for the searches in question, and even when they do, are they the difference that pushes you into the top 5 positions? Of course, if multiple services make sense under one umbrella than by all means keep them in one domain or even one page. As usual with SEO, the foundation is first making sure that what you're doing makes sense from a user perspective.