3 ms·
> They're all digital connections, so the signal/bits are either there or are not. Absolutely not true. There is quite a lot of engineering behind making an H
by jrockway 12y ago
> They're all digital connections, so the signal/bits are either there or are not.
Absolutely not true. There is quite a lot of engineering behind making an HDMI or Ethernet cable work:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transmission_line http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transmission_line
And, there are plenty of ways to mess it up and make a cable that only sort of works.
TMDS, the signaling mechanism that HDMI uses, does not have error correction codes. It does do some error detection by using 10 bits to transmit each 8 bit message and declaring some of the binary representations "invalid", but if the cable does not work well, you will get visual artifacts. (I was surprised when I saw this; little specks of green among blacks while I was running an HDMI cable very close to its maximum bandwidth. One video card I tested refused to output anything, but another was happy to send a signal that was corrupted by the cable.)
Further reading:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line_code http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line_code
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Differential_signaling http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Differential_signaling
- Alupis 12y agoAgain, the bits are either there or they are not (corruption). I don't see your point, because it seems to back my earlier point.
- rayiner 12y ago"Digital" is a fiction made possible by the heroic efforts of hardware designers. In the real world, every interconnect is an analog system. In "digital" interconnects like HDMI that don't have error correction, you can get artifacts before you lose the picture entirely.
- jrockway 12y agoBits are there, but the bits that come out of the video card may not be the bits that the TV sees. Like another comment says, it's all analog once you're outside of the computer, and the conversion between the two is not perfect. What digital signaling does is fix some common failure modes of analog. The signal is balanced, so it's more immune to picking up and emitting noise. The electrical signal only has two defined states, so if you degrade the signal in some way (attenuation, noise), you'll probably be able to pick the right state. But, you don't get infinite ability to do that, only more. Eventually, the two states become indistinguishable, and then you can't tell which bit was transmitted to you. (But you can't tell that you can't tell, so you start picking bits at random.) If we take this to the logical extreme, your argument implies that you can build an infinitely long cable with an infinitely tiny amount of material.
- tcas 12y agoThe 8b10b encoding mostly helps with clock recovery and preventing a DC bias (+/- charge) build up in the cable, which helps with error detection (I think it can detect only single bit) and recovery from, but can't correct.