2 ms·
Then you become the steward of the project and continue forward. Forking will introduce an untold number of new bugs, some of which may be worse than imagined.
by Alupis 12y ago
Then you become the steward of the project and continue forward. Forking will introduce an untold number of new bugs, some of which may be worse than imagined. Right now, native libressl only works on bsd's, when openssl codebase works on many os's. There are ports being made, which will introduce more bugs.
Bugs being in a tracker for years is not uncommon.
Here's OpenSSH's tracker:
https://bugzilla.mindrot.org/buglist.cgi?bug_status=__open__&content=&no_redirect=1&order=changeddate&product=Portable%20OpenSSH&query_based_on=&query_format=specific https://bugzilla.mindrot.org/buglist.cgi?bug_status=__open__...
331 bugs, a large majority of which are pre 2012.
This is not a sign of inactive/apathetic developers. It's a sign of big and old projects.
I have no doubt the OpenBSD folk are excited about this now... but 5 years from now? More? What's the long term viability of this project? Will they eventually put all OS's on an equal footing instead of *BSD's first and port to other OS's?
Forking was not the answer. The answer was to fix the perceived problems in OpenSSL and make it as solid as it can be. It's splitting talent and resources unnecessarily. Especially when the two projects are under the same umbrella (OpenBSD Foundation).
- chrismonsanto 12y ago> Then you become the steward of the project and continue forward. ... The answer was to fix the perceived problems in OpenSSL and make it as solid as it can be. It's splitting talent and resources unnecessarily. But that is what the fork is, OpenSSL with new stewards. What is your objection? That they are using a different name? That they decided to remove certain platforms which were a maintenance burden? That FIPS is broken by design and therefore isn't a priority? I imagine the OpenSSL team disagrees with the LibreSSL team on all of these issues. The only option was a fork. > Right now, native libressl only works on bsd's, when openssl codebase works on many os's. There are ports being made, which will introduce more bugs. One step backwards, two steps forward.
- krunaldo 12y agoMost of these are related to portable openssh and not openssh. These are two very different teams.