3 ms·
Nevertheless, the formulation that insurer profits account for the difference is simplistic and, in itself, woefully inadequate. Health insurance isn't a busin
by abalashov 17y ago
Nevertheless, the formulation that insurer profits account for the difference is simplistic and, in itself, woefully inadequate.
Health insurance isn't a business with such fat margins as to account for a difference between a $1500 MRI and a $98 MRI, say. That's the kind of rate the doctor charges the insurer, which in turn passes it on in a derivative way. The insurer is the customer.
Now, why doesn't an MRI cost something batshit insane like $1500 in other countries where the practitioners are also private? That's an interesting question. I don't think the cost controlling abilities of government committees or agencies account for the whole story; historically, committees of any kind - in the public or private sector - are pretty bad at keeping a lid on costs.
Still, I'd point the finger much more at doctors' profits than insurers' profits, though obviously neither is irrelevant.
I think this rather famous article treats of the matter fairly well:
http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/06/01/090601fa_fact_gawande http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/06/01/090601fa_fact_...
- GrandMasterBirt 17y agoThings about radeology and prices: Many people are not aware but it makes a BIG difference what radeologist you go to. The radeologist is the person who distinguises between a normal and abnormal growths. This is the specialist that can spot a tumor in a haystack! So you are paying for skills just like you pay for a surgeon, and no less important. In new york I haven't seen 1500 radeologists unless I go to some rich-people places. I pay about 400 bucks for my brain mris. Fortunately the insurance covers most of it. The price is for the doctor, the machine time (hey its an expensive machine), operator time, etc. Though some machines work much faster than others. (a 5-10 minute procedure vs a 30-50 minute one). And don't forget, lots of the great prices of lawyers suing doctors for everything are passed right on to you. And the fact that some americans are uninsured and have to be treated at hospitals means that those who are paying get to be charged extra to offset the problem. So yea a universal health care system would benefit everyone and drive down prices.
- pkulak 17y agoSome of the cost goes to profit/shareholders, but most of it's just pissed right down the drain with our 20% administrative rate.