3 ms·
An interesting question, I wonder if anyone has actually done this and tested where Sally really did first look for her ball. With the rearranged receptacles,
by RiderOfGiraffes 17y ago
An interesting question, I wonder if anyone has actually done this and tested where Sally really did first look for her ball. With the rearranged receptacles, I'll bet some children really would look in unexpected places first.
- jerf 17y agoWell, when I consulted my theory of mind, it said that Sally would yell at Denise for moving things around and loudly demand "Where's my ball?! Where's my ball?!" without necessarily assuming that it's still in the box where she left it. Once the room has been moved around by a "hostile" agent, who knows where anything is? But that wasn't one of the options, apparently. I'm not trying to be funny; that really is my "best guess" as to the resulting behavior. The question itself brings in the hidden assumption that Sally will see her only choices as "look for the ball in one of four places" and in the real world the situation is much less constrained; running to Mommy is likely to result. I'm not complaining about the hidden assumption, either; all such hypothetical questions bring in hidden assumptions, and it's fair to use them here.