3 ms·
Of course you can teach a rigorous English course. The problem is that you can also not. I took an intro to philosophy course in which we were graded reasonab
by jerf 12y ago
Of course you can teach a rigorous English course.
The problem is that you can also not.
I took an intro to philosophy course in which we were graded reasonably rigorously on our logic. But the prof also made it clear via both a bit of text and a bit of subtext that we were getting so graded because nobody really takes the old stuff that seriously anyhow, so there's no sacred oxes getting gored. You can write an essay for this class either endorsing or denouncing Descartes and as long as it is reasonably logical, you'll get a good grade. Don't expect such accommodations if you start getting into what is taken seriously.
I also took a real-deal English history class graded primarily on essays, and both at the time and even now I'm pretty sure I got a 2.5 simply because I failed to correctly echo back what the prof expected, made harder by the fact that she did a reasonably good job of not telegraphing what she expected. However, I never got any other useful feedback on my essays; the facts were correct, the arguments were logical enough, they were to the expected length, they just got graded poorly. (And it's not as if I was going out of my way to write offensive political agitprop myself, I was just trying to answer the questions. But I'm quite sure my perspective was quite different than hers, in ways hard to explain in an HN comment.)
The fact that you run a rigorous course grading logic and rhetoric (based on a computer science degree) is not proof that everybody else does. Yes, they all say that's what they do, but that's not proof either. In practice the humanities are pretty notorious for this sort of thing, and I'm completely unconvinced this essay with its one data point that is almost by definition an outlier (both coming from a computer science degree and being what is probably an early course in the sequence as implied by having a lot of non-English majors in it) provides any significant evidence against the original claims from Google, or that the field's notoriety is unearned in practice.
(Incidentally, to the extent that I rather dislike the humanities we have today, it is precisely that they could be excellent training in logic and rhetoric, but they generally aren't. Postmodernism poisoned the humanities nearly unto destruction.)
- Spooky23 12y agoYour position can apply to anything. There are Computer Science graduates who cannot tell you what a linked list is. You need to look for signals that imply humanities majors that are smart. Do they have published articles in student publications? Were they active in campus organizations? End of the day, look for smart people who get things done. If you need specific, rigorous domain expertise, hire somebody with a degree in that discipline of engineering or whatever. Otherwise, you're better off with a smart person who knows how to think and communicate vs. someone with an engineering degree who cannot function.
- jerf 12y ago"If you need specific, rigorous domain expertise, hire somebody with a degree in that discipline of engineering or whatever. Otherwise, you're better off with a smart person who knows how to think and communicate vs. someone with an engineering degree who cannot function." This is one of those cases where it sounds like you think you disagree, yet you just gave away the farm there. If you want a programmer, hire one trained in programming, you just agreed. As for whether you hire the functioning English major or the non-functional computer science major for a programming job, in practice, you hire neither. As for it "applying to everything", actually, my last paragraph is a parenthetical because I don't feel like justifying it deeply in an HN post when it would properly take a book, but there is a difference. Postmodernism killed the humanities. Evicting the entire idea of "truth" and calling that eviction virtue murders all further academic thought. (Yes, I'm summarizing. Brutally. But that is more true than it is false.) Even if that is true, it's still not an epistemological framework under which any academic function can take place. Computer science doesn't have that problem, all the moreso because the compiler grounds almost the entire discipline; certainly everything an undergraduate will encounter. It's hard for the humanities to brag about their ability to inculcate logical thought and careful rational reasoning when at the highest levels those things are despised.
- AnimalMuppet 12y agojerf's position can apply to anything. That doesn't mean that it applies to all things with equal probability, though. I'm fine with saying that there are rigorous English courses, and non-rigorous CS ones. But I still expect that, on average, the CS courses are more rigorous. Partly that's due to postmodernism, as jerf pointed out, but partly it's just because the subject matter of CS can be more rigorously defined and described than that of English.