3 ms·
The article mentions that his spread out, one-acre-per-person city "would be connected by a complex design of streets and highways." Is anyone familiar with hi
by saalweachter 12y ago
The article mentions that his spread out, one-acre-per-person city "would be connected by a complex design of streets and highways."
Is anyone familiar with his highway plan? My impression of city planning is that roads are the hard, boring part, so I'm curious if Wright's roads were just a thing he drew between his beautifully arranged buildings and parks, or if he had an actual plan for how to move people efficiently around his cities.
Saying "everyone should live close to their workplace" only works if you have a single, mega-office/industrial park, with all of the housing arranged tightly around it. Once you have two places people can work, changing jobs requires people to change houses, and only people who work together can live together. So in practice you need to have a transportation system that allows everyone in the city to commute between work and home in a short amount of time during a small window of time in the morning and afternoon.
Sitting in traffic in a beautifully designed city does not sound particularly more fun than sitting in traffic in a poorly designed city.
- peatmoss 12y agoI'm not familiar with his highway plan, but unless he figured out a way to transcend limitations of spacetime, providing transportation to an insane land use of one acre per person would be intractable. The common wisdom is that, due to latent demand, you can't really build your way out of congestion. That would be extra problematic under the land use you mention, as you'd be forcing everyone to drive everywhere (mass transit and walking are difficult when populations are diffuse and distances are vast). So, yeah, this strikes me as being a utopian vision by a talented architect dabbling in something outside his expertise.
- saraid216 12y ago> Saying "everyone should live close to their workplace" only works if you have a single, mega-office/industrial park, with all of the housing arranged tightly around it. You're assuming zoning. Check this out: office. And then put a house on top. More reasonably, do what I ended up having to do in SimCity: zone a couple spaces as commercial, then zone another couple spaces as residential, and then zone another couple spaces as commercial, and keep flipping back and forth.
- saalweachter 12y agoIt doesn't matter if you have zoning or intermingled commercial/residential. I work at Industrial Widgets, it's in an intermingled commercial/residential building, there's an apartment free on the three floors up from the very office. My wife currently works at Consolidated Sprockets across town. There's an apartment across the street. However, it's just an internship at she hopes to get a job at Conglomerated Weevils in a few months. It's located in a third location. Where should we live?
- saraid216 12y ago[edit] I wrote a thing about transportation, but I didn't realize you were criticizing Wright's plan, so nevermind; I've actually never found a reason to admire Wright and the article didn't really do anything for that.