4 ms·
Would this be a Lavabit-like situation? The governement asking for a backdoor and the developers are refusing it. Suddenly (while there is an audit), they quit
by NicoJuicy 12y ago
Would this be a Lavabit-like situation? The governement asking for a backdoor and the developers are refusing it.
Suddenly (while there is an audit), they quit everything, change the assemblies and the website, so users can get to another product... It seems weird that after 10 years of hard-work, they suddenly quit without further explanation.
- blueskin_ 12y agoIf so, I would at least like to think they would have likely pointed people towards something which gives at least comparable security, rather than a backdoored product.
- TelmoMenezes 12y agoSuppose someone has a girlfriend who is a vegetarian chef. She was kidnapped. The kidnappers forced her to make a phone call saying that everything is fine. She says "don't forget to buy some spam". At least she could have recommended something healthy?
- appleflaxen 12y agothat's the point: by recommending BitLocker, they are communicating a message to us that they are under duress.
- jeremyjh 12y agoYes and recommending Bitlocker is how they are trying to tip everyone off that this message is compromised.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jamesbrownuhh 12y agoReminiscent of Jeremiah Denton, the American prisoner of war in Vietnam, who was forced to appear before the cameras to say how well he was being treated - but used the opportunity to blink out "TORTURE" in morse code, to place those words in context. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeremiah_Denton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeremiah_Denton
- Crito 12y agoSee also, POWs 'flipping the bird' in propaganda photographs: http://www.usspueblo.org/Prisoners/The_Digit_Affair.html http://www.usspueblo.org/Prisoners/The_Digit_Affair.html
- danielweber 12y agoNo, there a big differences with Lavabit. Lavabit was a service, TrueCrypt is a product. Lavabit had access to all their customers' data, and told investigators that they had it. It's completely straightforward law that, given a subpoena, Lavabit must turn over evidence to the government. TrueCrypt is a product. They do not have access to customer data. There is no requirement for TrueCrypt to "help out the government" in this case. If you want to hang a conspiracy theory on this news[1], find some hook besides Lavabit. [1] And I can't fault the conspiracy theorists for trying to find some explanation over this, because the damn thing is so weird and unusual.
- Zigurd 12y ago> * There is no requirement for TrueCrypt to "help out the government" in this case.* That's what the publicly available laws say, but America has secret interpretations of laws now. We know, for example, that every Internet service is, in theory, free to provide tools that would put user data out of reach of anyone with, or without a warrant. And yet, nobody has. Nobody except Silent Circle, who have decided to domicile their company in Switzerland, is a new entrant based on the premise of providing truly secure communication. So, what to make of all the CEO-level complaining but no end-to-end encryption tools and no web-of-trust? If a major Internet portal provided end-to-end secure mail, real-time communications, and secure storage we would know that, yes, there is no legal or extralegal obligation to keep us all naked in the panopticon. But so far all the indicators are in the wrong direction.
- NicoJuicy 12y ago> publicly available law If you have a business in America, you signed the Patriot Act. That's probably the law they are using for coöperation :)
- Zigurd 12y agoThis is something to be precise about. You won't find language in the USA PATRIOT Act that tells businesses they may not provide privacy and security tools for their customers. Similarly, CALEA requires access to carriers' networks and equipment providers must support "lawful intercept" of a certain percentage of traffic, but there is nothing that would prevent networks from providing easy tools for end to end encryption and web-of-trust. The fact that nobody is doing that is a kind of probe. Do we really live in a free country, or is pervasive monitoring a condition being imposed on us, with no choice of services that would prevent it?